Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

Aaron Sharockman
By Aaron Sharockman August 20, 2010

Bill McCollum group attacks Rick Scott's new health care company Solantic

Can you believe it? There's another ad in the Republican primary for governor accusing Rick Scott of fraud.

This one comes from the Bill McCollum-backed group Florida First Initiative. But the subject isn't Columbia/HCA, the for-profit hospital company Scott helped build to become the nation's largest.

This ad is talking about some other, unnamed company.

The ad is called "Private." It opens with a narrator talking over newspaper headlines.

"Rick Scott's company pleaded guilty to one of the largest Medicare frauds in American history," the narrator says, referring to Columbia/HCA. Then, the screen flips to an image of Scott ripped from one of his commercials. It shows Scott saying: "And as CEO, I take responsibility."

The narrator returns. "And now, reporters have uncovered another Scott company accused of criminal acts. But Scott won't come clean."

Video returns to Scott. "It's a private matter," an angry-looking Scott says.

Then, the narrator responds. "Rick Scott, it's not a private matter. It's a failure of character."

The ad's final frame includes big type that spells out "Rick Scott," only the C and O of Scott's last name have been replaced by handcuffs. As the ad ends, the handcuffs interlock. If our meter measured tackiness, that over-the-top symbolism would rate pretty high, but in this case we can only examine the facts surrounding the ad.

So we decided to look at this statement: "Reporters have uncovered another Scott company accused of criminal acts. But Scott won't come clean."

Scott company background

The narrator doesn't identify the company in question by name, but when he makes the claim a tearsheet of an Aug. 5, 2010, St. Petersburg Times article appears on the screen.

The article is titled "Lawsuits point to trouble at Rick Scott's current health care business."

That headline refers to this story about a company Scott co-founded in 2001, Solantic.

Solantic is a chain of walk-in urgent care centers, primarily around northeast Florida. The company currently operates 30 walk-in centers across the state.

The article, which was written by the Miami Herald and St. Petersburg Times reported that Scott was deposed in a Solantic civil suit just six days before he announced his bid for governor.

The suit, brought by Dr. P. Mark Glencross, alleged that Glencross' medical license was misused by the Jacksonville-based chain of walk-in clinics. Glencross said Solantic, without his knowledge, used his name in 2004 when it filed state paperwork designed to ensure that clinics have a medical director in charge.

Featured Fact-check

Within a month of Scott's deposition, the 2-year-old case was settled and both parties signed a confidentiality agreement.

The story went on to mention nine other court actions filed against Solantic since 2001, which were settled. Solantic chief executive Karen Bowling told Herald/Times reporter Marc Caputo that Solantic settled the cases at the request of its insurance company, which found protracted court fights too expensive.

A spokesman for Scott noted that while he is a major investor in Solantic, he doesn't run its day-to-day operations, and that Scott was involved in only two of the suits.

A few days later, on Aug. 10, Scott appeared at a Tallahassee press conference where reporters asked him repeatedly if he would release the sealed deposition in the Glencross case.

That's when Scott provided the line used in the Florida First Initiative ad: "It's a private matter," he said. Later in the press conference he said: "It's a private matter and I will not release the deposition."

Glencross case is civil, not criminal

Based on the whole of the ad -- the words of the narrator, the clips flashed on the screen, and the choice of Scott's words -- viewers and fact-checkers are left to assume that the ad is talking about the Solantic/Glencross case.

In that case, there are two large distortions.

First, the Solantic/Glencross case is a civil matter, not a criminal one. There are no charges of criminal wrongdoing.

Second, the allegation that Scott won't come clean is misleading. He gave a deposition.

He just has said he won't share that deposition with reporters. He has no legal requirement to do so, either.

We tried to reach the registered agent of Florida First Initiative, J. Nottingham, for an explanation. But the number on file at the Florida Division of Elections rang dead.

We should note that there is another allegation surrounding Solantic currently making news. Another former Solantic physician, Dr. Randy Prokes, sent an e-mail to the McCollum campaign claiming that Solantic billed Medicare at full rates for patients seen by a nurse practitioner, when federal rules require that billing be at 85 percent of the fee paid for physician examinations.

The McCollum campaign passed the letter on to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

The FDLE then sent the letter on to the inspector general’s office at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

That's where the letter sits today. There is no formal investigation. Solantic executives, meanwhile, have described Prokes as a disgruntled former employee who was fired in 2009 for fraudulently prescribing drugs last year.

Even if Prokes' claim has merit, it's not what the Florida First Initiative ad is referencing based on the ads visuals and wording. So we're not considering it.

Our ruling

The ad says that "reporters have uncovered another Scott company accused of criminal acts. But Scott won't come clean."

The line refers to a civil lawsuit involving Solantic, a company Scott co-founded, and Dr. Gary Glencross. Glencross alleged that his medical license was misused by the Jacksonville-based chain of walk-in clinics. A month after Scott gave a deposition in the case, it was settled. Terms of the settlement are confidential.

The case was a civil one, not criminal. And Scott provided a deposition as required. The only instance of him failing to "come clean" is not providing the results of that deposition to the public. Which he doesn't have to. We rate the accusation False.

Our Sources

Florida First Initiative, "Private," Aug. 17, 2010

Rick Scott campaign, e-mail interviews with Jennifer Baker, Aug. 19, 2010

Solantic, history of the company, accessed Aug. 20, 2010

St. Petersburg Times, "Lawsuits point to trouble at Rick Scott's current health care business," Aug. 5, 2010

St. Petersburg Times, "Defiant Rick Scott assails suit over sealed testimony, says McCollum abusing power," Aug. 11, 2010

Duval County court records, Solantic v. Gary Glencross, accessed Aug. 20, 2010

Florida Division of Elections, Florida First Initiative filing documents, accessed Aug. 20, 2010

Orlando Sentinel, The Scott-McCollum Solantic opus (CliffsNotes version), Aug. 11, 2010

Orlando Sentinel, FDLE passes Solantic complaint to the feds, Aug. 16, 2010

Naples Daily News, "Complaint against clinics owned by Rick Scott sent to federal investigators," Aug. 16, 2010

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Aaron Sharockman

Bill McCollum group attacks Rick Scott's new health care company Solantic

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up