Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

Rep. Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., speaks during the Democratic National Convention, Aug. 21, 2024, in Chicago. (AP) Rep. Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., speaks during the Democratic National Convention, Aug. 21, 2024, in Chicago. (AP)

Rep. Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., speaks during the Democratic National Convention, Aug. 21, 2024, in Chicago. (AP)

Maria Ramirez Uribe
By Maria Ramirez Uribe November 15, 2024

Nancy Pelosi’s wrong comparison about illegal immigration under Joe Biden, Donald Trump

If Your Time is short

  • Border Patrol agents have encountered people trying to illegally cross the border between official ports of entry 7.2 million times under President Joe Biden’s administration compared with 1.8 million times under President-elect Donald Trump’s first term.

  • Pelosi’s team didn’t respond to PolitiFact’s request for comment, but it pointed The Washington Post to deportation data as evidence for her statement. 

  • Biden has carried out more total repatriations — sending people out of the U.S. — than Trump. But that’s not evidence that fewer people were let into the U.S. than under Trump. ​

In a New York Times interview about the 2024 election, Rep. Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., said the Democrats lost partly because of cultural issues. Journalist Lulu Garcia-Navarro, co-host of "The Interview," pointed out that most voters said they voted on inflation, the economy and immigration. 

"Those aren’t cultural issues," Garcia-Navarro said. "Those are policy issues."

Pelosi countered, "When the candidate for president is saying that these people coming in are murderers, rapists, thieves and all the rest of that. He made that a cultural issue."

Garcia-Navarro said millions of people crossed the U.S. border under President Joe Biden’s administration. Pelosi said, "I don’t think we were clear enough by saying fewer people came in under President Biden than came under Donald Trump."

Illegal immigration under Biden has dropped significantly in the past four months, reaching levels lower than President-elect Donald Trump’s last few months in office. But it’s wrong to say illegal immigration, which reached historic highs under Biden, is lower overall than it was during Trump’s first term.

Pelosi’s office did not respond to PolitiFact’s request for comment, but illegal immigration data contradict Pelosi’s claim. A Pelosi aide told The Washington Post that Pelosi was referring to deportation data. That data shows that Biden’s administration repatriated more people than Trump did, but that’s not what Pelosi said in the interview.

What the data on illegal migration shows 

From February 2021, Biden’s first full month in office, to September 2024, the latest month with data, U.S. Border Patrol agents encountered migrants trying to illegally cross U.S. borders between ports of entry 7.2 million times.

Under Trump’s administration, from February 2017 to January 2021, Border Patrol encountered immigrants between ports of entry 1.8 million times. 

The encounters data does not represent how many people were let into the U.S; there’s no specific data for that. But according to federal data, Customs and Border Protection released about 313,000 people under Trump’s administration and about 3.6 million people under Biden’s administration, to await court hearings. (Biden’s data includes people given humanitarian parole, a legal authorization to live and work in the U.S. for up to two years.)

Based on the available data, fewer people did not come to the U.S. under Biden than under Trump, as Pelosi claimed. But there are important caveats about the data to consider.

The pandemic changed data tracking: Before March 2020, border data tracked the times people were apprehended crossing the border illegally under immigration law. During the pandemic, the Trump and Biden administrations apprehended people under that law. But officials also began tracking expulsions under a public health policy, Title 42. People expelled under this policy were not let into the country; whereas people apprehended under immigration law in some cases could still be let in.

Starting in fiscal year 2020, U.S. Customs and Border Protection began reporting encounters, a combination of apprehensions and Title 42 expulsions. (Title 42 enforcement ended in May 2023.) 

So, the change in immigration data tracking makes it hard to fairly compare entries across different administrations.

Encounters represent events not people: Not everyone encountered is let into the country. Immigration data represents events, not people. If one person tries to enter the country three times and is stopped each time by border officials, for example, that equals three encounters, even if it’s the same person encountered. People expelled under Title 42 were not penalized for repeat attempted entries, so many tried coming in multiple times.

In recent months, encounters have drastically dropped: In June, Biden issued a policy limiting people’s ability to apply for asylum at the southwest border. Since then, Border Patrol encounters at the U.S.-Mexico border have dropped sharply, from more than 117,000 in May to fewer than 54,000 in September. 

From July to September, monthly Border Patrol encounter counts have been below the counts during Trump’s last four months in office.

Despite the data caveats and the drop in encounters in the past few months, Pelosi’s claim that fewer people came into the U.S. under Biden than under Trump is inaccurate.

What the deportation data shows

As with encounters data, comparing prepandemic deportation data to deportation data during the public health emergency is challenging. There are multiple ways people can be repatriated — sent back to their home country or another country that will accept them. 

  • Removals: This is when people are sent out of the U.S. via an official court order, often penalized for the illegal entry. This can include people who have lived in the United States for years and people who recently arrived. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement is usually involved.

  • Returns: This happens at the border when people are returned to their home countries without legal penalties and without being placed in formal removal proceedings. 

  • Title 42 expulsions: These happened from March 2020 to May 2023 under the public health policy. Many people arriving at the border were not let into the United States and were expelled without legal penalties.

When combining the data for all these types of repatriations, Biden has sent out more people than Trump did (4.3 million compared with 2.2 million.)

But when looking only at Immigration and Customs Enforcement data, Trump removed more people than Biden did (about 294,000 compared with about 114,000.)

We asked immigration experts whether more encounters under Biden factored in the higher number of total repatriations under his administration. They said only partly, because despite the rise in illegal immigration encounters, the resources available for deportations have remained largely the same.

"The government has a finite capacity to identify, detain, and remove individuals, so it is not as if removals capacity can be dramatically scaled up or down based on a changing encounters picture," Michelle Mittelstadt, the nonpartisan think tank Migration Policy Institute’s communications director, told PolitiFact in September.

The rise in encounters influenced the decrease in Immigration and Customs Enforcement removals. Biden focused on repatriating people at the U.S. border, rather than deporting people who have been living in the U.S. for decades. Biden also had more total repatriations because he executed quick public health expulsions that didn’t require court orders much longer than Trump did. 

Also, under Biden, many more immigrants came from countries other than Mexico, El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras than under Trump. It is harder to deport migrants from those other countries for "legal and logistical reasons," a Migration Policy Institute report said.

Our ruling

Pelosi said, "Fewer people came in under President Biden than came under Donald Trump." 

Under Biden, Border Patrol agents encountered migrants trying to enter the U.S.7.2 million times; under Trump, officials encountered migrants 1.8 million times. Encounters don’t mean people were let in, and there’s no data for how many people who were encountered are now living in the U.S. But the numbers of people released to await court hearings don’t corroborate Pelosi’s statement, either. There were about 313,000 under Trump compared with 3.6 million under Biden.

Pelosi’s team didn’t respond to PolitiFact’s request for comment. But it told The Washington Post that Pelosi was talking about deportation data.

Overall, Biden has carried out more total repatriations — sending people out of the U.S. — than Trump. But that’s not evidence that fewer people were let into the U.S. than under Trump. 

We rate Pelosi’s statement False.

Our Sources

The New York Times, The Interview Nancy Pelosi Insists the Election Was Not a Rebuke of the Democrats, Nov. 9, 2024

PolitiFact, Kamala Harris correct that immigration at the U.S. southern border has been cut by half or more, Oct. 24, 2024

The Washington Post, Pelosi’s flawed claim that Biden did better than Trump on the border, Nov. 13, 2024

Reuters, Biden is now deporting more people than Trump, July 8, 2023

U.S. Customs and Border Protection, Nationwide Encounters, accessed Nov. 15, 2024

Office of Homeland Statistics, Immigration Enforcement, accessed Nov. 15, 2024

PolitiFact, Immigration experts say JD Vance is wrong. Haitians under temporary programs are in the US legally., Oct. 3, 2024

PolitiFact, Title 42 expiration: What's next for migrants applying for asylum at US’ southern border?, Oct. 8, 2023

PolitiFact, Donald Trump is wrong. Joe Biden doesn’t have an ‘immunity from deportation’ policy., March 15, 2024

Migration Policy Institute, Record-Breaking Migrant Encounters at the U.S.-Mexico Border Overlook the Bigger Story, October 2022

Migration Policy Institute, The Biden Administration Is on Pace to Match Trump Deportation Numbers—Focusing on the Border, Not the U.S. Interior, June 27, 2024

The Washington Post, Pelosi’s flawed claim that Biden did better than Trump on the border, Nov. 13, 2024

Email interview, David Bier, Director of Immigration Studies at the CATO Institute, Sept. 4, 2024

Email interview ,Michelle Mittelstadt, Director of Communications at the Migration Policy Institute, Sept. 4, 2024

Email interview, Aaron Reichlin Melnick, Senior fellow at the American Immigration Council, Sept. 4, 2024

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Maria Ramirez Uribe

Nancy Pelosi’s wrong comparison about illegal immigration under Joe Biden, Donald Trump

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up