Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Amid a growing awareness that sex trafficking is a problem in Rhode Island, the public access program "State of the State" broadcast a discussion of the issue. During the show, host Rebecca Quigley offered several statistics about sex workers. One in particular caught our ear.
"Once a woman enters into the sex trade," she said, "her average life expectancy is seven years, with AIDS and homicide as the top killers."
So if a 18-year-old woman starts working as a prostitute, she's likely to be dead by age 25?
We decided to check out that provocative statistic.
In contrast, we located a 2004 study in the American Journal of Epidemiology that used 33 years of data to examine the lives of female prostitutes in Colorado Springs, Colorado. Nearly 2,000 were ultimately tracked. Some had been in the business for a few years, others for much longer.
The researchers found that fewer than 8 percent died over the three decades.
When we tracked down the authors, they said the actual life expectancy, like so many statistics used in the prostitution debate, isn't really known. But, they said, it's not seven years.
"If you had a life expectancy that short, you'd have difficulty replenishing the pool with new prostitutes," said coauthor Devon D. Brewer, who directs Interdisciplinary Scientific Research, a Seattle-based research and consulting firm. "It's tough to put into words how dramatic an overstatement that is. There's zero basis that I'm aware of for making statements like that."
"The truth is, the vast majority of women who enter into prostitution leave the trade alive, so to say a life expectancy of seven years . . . There is no basis for anything that incredibly dramatic," he said.
"That's a statement that gains credence because it's repeated so often and it perhaps has very little to do with reality," said chief author John J. Potterat, now retired from the El Paso County Department of Health and Environment in Colorado Springs.
When we heard back from Quigley, she cited several sources we had seen that made the same claim, including an article from Emergency Physicians Monthly that traced a variant of the claim to Melissa Farley, clinical psychologist, founder and director of Prostitution Research and Education, based in San Francisco. She's an anti-prostitution activist.
Farley told us that, although she's heard the statistic, she's never seen any documentation to back it up.
What is true, the experts all agreed, is that prostitution is a very dangerous profession.
The fact that the seven-year statistic is wrong, said Brewer, the Seattle scholar, "doesn't take away from the fact that the risk of death that prostitute women face is higher than any other set of women ever studied, at least the risk of homicide. Does that mean most prostitutes are getting killed? No. It means compared to other women in other professions it's the one you're mostly likely to be murdered in."
Brewer and his colleagues estimated that the women they studied faced a 1 percent chance of being murdered during their prostitution career.
That murder rate, by the way, has also spawned another bogus statistic — that prostitutes typically die around age 34. What Brewer, Potterat and their colleagues actually found was that among the 21 prostitutes in their study who were murdered, their average age when they died was 34.
As retired call girl Maggie McNeill noted last year in the Washington Post, to say that's "the average life expectancy of all street workers, or of all sex workers . . . would be analogous to saying that because the average soldier who is killed in battle is 21 years old, the average man who joins the military dies at 21."
Quigley's best source supporting her claim — and one we found as well — was the FBI.
In an FBI document titled "FY 2011 Budget Request At A Glance," the bureau asks for $333 million and 831 positions to fight child exploitation. The fact sheet claims, "Studies estimate between 200,000 and 300,000 children are being forced into prostitution at any given time in the United States. The average age of a new child prostitute is 13, and the life expectancy after becoming a child prostitute is 7 years." No source is cited. We couldn't find another FBI document that repeated the seven-year claim.
So the FBI was only talking about child prostitution, not prostitution in general.
And when we contacted the FBI, the agency repudiated the statistic.
Spokesman Christopher M. Allen said that after checking with the bureau's Violent Crimes Against Children Section, it appears that the seven-year life expectancy claim may have come from a case the FBI handled, one that involved several victims.
"It should not be considered a general statement of FBI findings," Allen wrote in an email.
Rebecca Quigley said, "Once a woman enters into the sex trade, her average life expectancy is seven years."
She — like many others on the Internet — are incorrectly quoting a FBI budget report that only deals with child prostitution and offers no documentation. And the FBI is now trying to set the record straight.
There’s little doubt that prostitution can be one of the most dangerous endeavors undertaken by a woman. But the seven-year claim is flat out False.
(If you have a claim you’d like PolitiFact Rhode Island to check, email us at email@example.com. And follow us on Twitter: @politifactri.)
Stateofthestateri.com, "5-14-2015 Sex for Sale; Sex Trafficking, Harassment and Stalking," May 14, 2015, accessed May 22, 2015
AJE.OxfordJournals.org, "Mortality in a Long-term Open Cohort of Prostitute Women," American Journal of Epidemiology, 2004, accessed May 22, 2015
Justice.gov, "FY 2011 Budget Request At A Glance," Federal Bureau of Investigation, undated, accessed May 22, 2015
Emails, Rebecca Quigley, host, State of the State, May 25, 2015, Donna M. Hughes, sex trafficking researcher and professor, University of Rhode Island, May 26, 2015 and Christopher M. Allen, spokesman, Federal Bureau of Investigation, May 27, 2015
WashingtonPost.com, "Lies, damned lies, and sex work statistics," March 27, 2014, accessed May 22, 2015
Interviews, John J. Potterat, retired, El Paso County Department of Health and Environment in Colorado Springs; Devon D. Brewer, director, Interdisciplinary Scientific Research, Seattle; and Melissa Farley, clinical psychologist, founder and director of Prostitution Research and Education, all May 26, 2015
ProstitutionResearch.com, "How Many Juveniles are Involved in Prostitution in the U.S.?" Crimes against Children Research Center, University of New Hampshire, 2008, and "Prostitution and Trafficking - Quick Facts," 2012, both accessed May 26, 2015
Eminism.org, "Some thoughts on the Newsweek story on the new Farley 'research,'" July 19, 2011, accessed May 22, 2015
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.