Get PolitiFact in your inbox.
A new ad from a Republican-backed super PAC has a scary message about Democrat Dan Feehan for voters in Minnesota’s 1st Congressional District:
"Gang members and criminals" are marching toward the U.S. southern border in a caravan with thousands of potential immigrants from Central America — and if Feehan were elected, he just might let everyone in.
The ad from the Congressional Leadership Fund, hoping to keep a Republican majority in the U.S. House, juxtaposes the march-toward-the-border footage with a question:
"Who is tough enough to secure our border? Not Dan Feehan. In Washington, Feehan would vote with Pelosi for open borders and amnesty, putting Minnesota families at risk."
The concern about criminals has been heard since President Donald Trump stated it in tweets, speeches and remarks to reporters. Numerous news stories say the march that started in Honduras is full of people fleeing violence and economic turmoil. But Tyler Q. Houlton, spokesman for the Department of Homeland Security, said in a tweet on Oct. 23 that the department "can confirm that there are individuals within the caravan who are gang members or have significant criminal histories."
It is uncertain what will happen when the crowd arrives at the United States border, where some are expected to request asylum. Trump is working to increase barriers to entry and has spoken of sending soldiers, saying the caravan is "an assault on our country."
Would Feehan really vote for open borders, and for that matter, would Pelosi?
We went to find out.
Few if any lawmakers and congressional aspirants have a policy that addresses the question, What to do about caravans? But none say they want to throw open the borders.
Since the CLF says Feehan would vote for open borders and for amnesty, we asked his campaign if that’s what he wants.
"Dan obviously does not," Sara Severs, Feehan spokeswoman, said. "As a decorated Iraq combat veteran, the safety and the security of this nation is personal to Dan and he believes our nation needs to secure our borders and pass comprehensive immigration reform to address our immigration challenges."
Feehan’s campaign website includes a page dedicated solely to immigration. He says he wants "a pathway to citizenship for those who pay their taxes and don’t have a criminal record."
He wants to hold "employers who hire undocumented immigrants accountable," and develop "a robust guest worker program."
He also says that as a veteran, "when it comes to public safety, let me be perfectly clear, no matter who you are, if you commit a violent crime, you must be punished."
In that vein, his ideas are similar to what House Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi and others have proposed.
Immigration and border debates over recent years have concerned what to do about immigrants who seek asylum, how to treat immigrants who got in without authorization, and whether to build a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border, as Trump wants.
The rhetoric has grown heated following large-scale deportations of immigrants here illegally, and separation of children from their parents.
"I don’t see any of us voting for wall funding," Pelosi told Politico recently. "We have a responsibility to secure our borders. There are ways to do that that are consistent with civilization, humanitarianism and who we are as a nation."
She also said she wants to work on protecting so-called Dreamers, undocumented young adults who were brought to the U.S. as children. In 2013, she supported proposals to create a way for others here illegally to stay, while also doubling the number of border patrol agents to at least 38,405, adding hundreds more miles of border fencing and requiring the Obama administration to have a plan to apprehend 90 percent of attempted border crossings.
The proposed legislation was similar to a 2013 bipartisan Senate bill, the Border Security, Economic Opportunity and Immigration Modernization Act, that passed with support from 14 Republicans and every Democrat. In the House, however, Republicans favored working on enforcement first, with some saying a path to citizenship would disadvantage U.S.-born citizens for jobs.
One point of criticism of the Senate bill was that it would have allowed undocumented immigrants to apply for Registered Provisional Immigrant (RPI) status only if they had not been convicted of a felony or three or more misdemeanors. That means, as the Congressional Leadership Fund said in materials it sent us in support of its ad, that people who had committed two misdemeanors could qualify.
The ad, however does not say that, focusing instead on "gang members and criminals" the super PAC says are marching to the country now. Under the Senate bill, applicants would have had to be living in this country already before they could qualify to apply.
The Congressional Leadership Fund says Dan Feehan "would vote with Pelosi for open borders and amnesty, putting Minnesota families at risk."
There is no question Feehan holds views contrary to the president’s and those of many House Republicans. He wants to find a way for people who are in this country already to stay, under certain conditions.
But nothing in his positions suggests he supports open borders and total amnesty. There is a lot of either-or posturing in politics, and this is no different, but the CLF’s extreme framing of Feehan’s positions calls for a harsh ruling: False.
Congressional Leadership Fund ad, "Caravan," Oct. 26, 2018
Email and telephone conversation with Michael Byerly, spokesman, Congressional Leadership Fund, Oct. 26, 2018
Email exchange with Sara Severs, spokeswoman, Dan Feehan for Congress, Oct. 26. 2018
Telephone conversation with Drew Hammill, spokesman, House Minority Leader nancy Pelosi, Oct. 26, 2018
Politico, "Pelosi gives Playbook a preview of the Democratic majority," Oct. 16, 2018
Politico, "Pelosi details her plans for House majority," Oct 16, 2018
The Hill, "Pelosi rallies Democrats behind sweeping immigration package," Oct. 3, 2013
American Immigration Council, "A Guide to S.744: Understanding the 2013 Senate Immigration Bill," July 10, 2013
Associated Press, "Immigration bill summary," June 28, 2013
Dan Feehan for Congress website, "Immigration"
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.