Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
In the special election to fill Tom Price’s former House seat, Republican Karen Handel often reminds voters of a key line in her political resume.
"As chairman of the Fulton board of commissioners, I turned a $100 million deficit into a balanced budget," she said in an 11Alive news report.
The claim is the second sentence on her biography page on her website.
Which raises the question: Did Handel actually turn a $100 million deficit into a balanced budget?
The short answer is that while Handel was able to help balance the county budget without raising taxes, her specific claim ignores some critical facts about the Fulton County budget process.
Let’s step back in time.
Diving into the ‘deficit’
Handel took over as chair of the county commissioners on Nov. 12, 2003. Two days later, she was handed a proposed 2004 budget.
It was a balanced budget because by law, it had to be.
But in two of the county’s largest funds, the general fund and the special services district fund, the original budget planners saw spending topping revenues by a combined total of nearly $90 million.
They didn’t call those deficits; they called them shortfalls. But the concept is similar. Additional shortfalls in other funds added well over $10 million to the gap, giving us the $100 million "deficit" in Handel’s claim.
To keep the budget balanced, that original plan took $12 million from the county’s cash reserves (to boost the general fund) and raised property taxes by about $75 million.
To be clear, the difference is not that Handel took an unbalanced budget and fixed it. Rather, she took a different approach to balancing the budget — which, again, by law, the commission had to do each year.
Looking at news reports in January 2004, Handel gets credit for using a mix of spending cuts and deeper draws into cash reserves to deliver a balanced budget that avoided a property tax increase.
Overall, her budget plan reduced spending by $46 million from the plan she saw when she took office. But that still didn’t close the gap between spending and revenues.
The gap was half of what she started with. She filled that gap, not with more property taxes, but with money saved from past years and kept in reserve.
In the words of a Jan. 22, 2004, Atlanta Journal Constitution article, "The budget calls for $49 million in deficit spending that pulls Fulton's two savings accounts below commission-mandated minimums." (Ultimately, the funds didn't dip as low as expected.)
We spoke with Handel and her spokeswoman Kate Constantini. They rejected the idea that her plan included a "deficit" but agreed with the numbers.
"I came in and got the budget in place so we didn't need to raise taxes," Handel said. "We did that through savings and realignment across the various funds."
The Atlanta Journal Constitution praised her at the time. In an editorial, it called her plan "reasonable and even handed."
"In this era of cruel budget-cutting in the face of dropping revenue, it’s a rare opportunity to adopt a spending plan that supports good services but doesn’t soak the taxpayers," it said.
Handel said she turned a $100 million deficit into a balanced budget when she became chair of the Fulton County board of commissioners.
Certain parts of that story add up: The expected shortfall was over $100 million. Handel’s budget was balanced, and did so without a tax increase.
However, her talking point omits that the county required balanced budgets — and the spending plan she was handed was balanced in the first place.
Furthermore, if Handel called the $100 million in the original plan a deficit, then the same label would apply to the 2004 budget that she spearheaded. Her balanced plan also factored in a $49 million shortfall, even after spending cuts.
The biggest difference is she avoided a hefty tax hike by drawing more from reserves.
Words matter. Handel’s statement ignores that she was required to balance the budget, and her definition of deficit is inconsistent. We rate this claim Half True.
11Alive News, Race to replace Tom Price: Karen Handel touting past record, March 21, 2017
Karen Handel for Congress, About Karen, accessed April 12, 2017
Fulton County Department of Finance, 2004 budget proposal letter, Nov. 14, 2003
Atlanta Journal Constitution, Fulton budget passed, Jan. 22, 2004
Atlanta Journal Constitution, Editorial: approve sensible Fulton budget, Jan. 14, 2004
Interview, Karen Handel, congressional candidate, April 13, 2017
Interview, Kate Constantini, spokeswoman, Handel for Congress, April 14, 2017
Interview, Clint Mueller, legislative director, Association County Commissioners of Georgia, April 13, 2017
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.