Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

Katie McGinty speaks after winning SEIU endorsement. Credit: Facebook Katie McGinty speaks after winning SEIU endorsement. Credit: Facebook

Katie McGinty speaks after winning SEIU endorsement. Credit: Facebook

By Mark Dent October 4, 2016

Ex-DEP secretary McGinty (legally) profited from the environmental business

The attack ads are upon us. It’s difficult to sit through any newscast or sporting event without seeing one, and ads for Senate candidates Katie McGinty and Pat Toomey are filling up the Pennsylvania airwaves like nowhere else. Outside groups have contributed $57.5 million on the Toomey-McGinty race -- more than any other Senate battle in the country.  

One recent anti-McGinty ad comes from the Freedom Partners Action Fund, a Republican-leaning PAC involved in Senate races in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Wisconsin, Nevada and Indiana. The ad, which Freedom Partners Action Fund backed with $1 million, calls her out for taking jobs related to her past government work, stating, "she’s made thousands from companies she previously regulated."

McGinty had several jobs and advisory positions after her work as Secretary of the Department of Environmental Protection in Governor Ed Rendell’s administration. Were those companies’ business under the purview of the DEP? And did she really make thousands?

After leaving Rendell’s administration, according to her LinkedIn profile, McGinty worked as a director for NRG Energy for three years, senior VP and managing director of strategic growth for Weston Solutions for two and chair of Fresh Start PA for five months. She also advised for the solar energy company Plextronics and served as a board member of Iberdrola, a wind-energy and natural gas company.   

For NRG, she was pulling in six figures annually. According to SEC filings from NRG Energy, McGinty made $200,000 in cash and stock in 2011 and $146,000 in 2009. Penn Live reported Iberdrola paid McGinty $125,000 for her work on the board.  

Would those firms fall under the DEP’s umbrella? DEP press secretary Neil Shader said the DEP regulates the activities of energy companies, as well as others related to the environment.  

Asked whether it took issue with the statement about McGinty making thousands "from companies she previously regulated," the McGinty campaign responded with a statement that essentially ignored our question. The campaign said only that "Katie has dedicated her career in both the public and private sector to creating good paying jobs and protecting the environment. She has a long record of accomplishment, including bringing $1 billion renewable energy investments to Pennsylvania and creating 3,000 jobs as Secretary of PA's Department of Environmental Protection."

Featured Fact-check

In Pennsylvania, for the most part there are few laws prohibiting the type of work a public official can do after leaving office. One exception is lobbying. Public officials are barred from lobbying the agency at which they worked for a year after they left.

It’s not uncommon for Democrats or Republicans to move into private sector jobs related to their past positions in government. Michael Krancer, for instance, joined Blank Rome’s energy, industry team after his tenure as DEP secretary under Tom Corbett.

Barry Kauffmann, executive director of the state watchdog group Common Cause, would like to see that prohibition extended for two years and the introduction of regulations for public officials who take private sector jobs closely related to their previous position.       

"The problem is conflict of interest," he said. "You need to have a buffer or a barrier to make sure the public is protected from the conflict of interest. And there has to be penalties to make sure those disincentives are in place and effectively monitored."  

Our ruling

The pro-Republican PAC Freedom Partners Action Fund attacked Senate candidate Katie McGinty in a recent ad, stating, "she’s made thousands from companies she previously regulated."

After McGinty stopped working as DEP secretary in 2008, she worked for or served on the board for energy companies NRG Energy, Iberdrola and Plextronics, among others. NRG Energy and Iberdrola both compensated her with more than $100,000. According to the Department of Environmental Protection, the office is responsible for regulating the activities of energy companies.

We rule the claim True.

Our Sources

Ad via YouTube. "Last Time." Freedom Partners Action Fund.

Email interview. Freedom Partners Action Fund. October 3, 2016.

Email interview. McGinty Campaign. October 4, 2016.

LinkedIn. Katie McGinty.

News article. "Katie McGinty may return to Washington with U.S. Senate bid." Penn Live. October 3, 2016.

News article. "McGinty to advise Plextronics." Solar Industry. October 3, 2016.

Phone Interview. Barry Kauffmann, executive director Common Cause. October 3, 2016.

SEC filing, NRG Energy. February 29, 2012.

SEC filing, NRG Energy. April 2, 2009.

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Mark Dent

Ex-DEP secretary McGinty (legally) profited from the environmental business

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up