Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker appeared on 'Fox News Sunday' while in Washington for the National Governors Association. Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker appeared on 'Fox News Sunday' while in Washington for the National Governors Association.

Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker appeared on 'Fox News Sunday' while in Washington for the National Governors Association.

By Dave Umhoefer February 13, 2015

Did Scott Walker flip-flop on how budget shortfalls are measured??

It’s a favorite talking point of Gov. Scott Walker, one he’s taking national as he charges up a potential presidential campaign:

He inherited a $3.6 billion budget shortfall from Democratic Gov. Jim Doyle, but dug out of it by cutting costs and limiting union bargaining power with state and local government.

Walker even dropped the figure into his well-received January 2015  speech at an Iowa cattle call for 2016 Republican presidential hopefuls.

So our eyebrows went up Feb. 6, 2015 when Walker was questioned about his stewardship of the state budget by Fox News anchor Bret Baier in a profile on the rising presidential hopes of the Wisconsin governor.

During the interview, Baier said: "You talk about $2 billion in (tax) savings for individuals and businesses, but you also have a $2.2 billion budget shortfall in the coming two years."

Walker immediately questioned the credibility of the $2.2 billion number and portrayed it as a media creation.

"I would contend that’s based on numbers from some of the Wisconsin media outlets as if everybody who asked for anything got it," Walker said. "Even in your own household budget that never happens."

Has Walker changed his view on the validity of these shortfall estimates now that he’s in the governor’s chair?

This is another one for the Flip-O-Meter.

Our standard disclaimer applies: The Flip-O-Meter is not designed to say whether any change in position is good policy or good politics. Rather, it strictly looks at whether a public official has been consistent in his or her stated views on a topic.

Let’s go back to November 2010, shortly after his election to replace Doyle.

Walker pounced on the numbers from a statutorily required report by the state Department of Administration that showed -- in combination with other debts -- Walker would inherit a $3.6 billion shortfall six months after taking office in January 2011.

Time and again …. and again … Walker used that number to portray the state as broke, and to explain the cuts he proposed -- and which were ultimately made -- in public education funding and other programs.

We, and other media outlets, examined the figure then and declared it credible, as far as it goes.

Featured Fact-check

As we’ve explained, it’s not a "deficit" number as Walker and others in Madison often call it. It’s a pre-budget estimate designed to illustrate the size of the shortfall or challenge the governor faces when putting together a budget.

The shortfall figure includes all the requests from state departments, and also predictions of how much tax revenue the state will collect.

Fast forward to the Fox interview.

Walker said the report of a $2.2 billion shortfall heading into his budget was a media creation.

But the fact is, it came from a report from his own budget shop in his Department of Administration.

What’s more, tax cuts pushed by Walker and Republicans in the Legislature play into some of the challenge that faced budget-makers, as projected revenues have fallen short.

But by far the biggest chunk of the $2.2 billion projection is -- as Walker alluded to on Fox -- the spending increases sought by state agencies.

But that’s always been the case. That’s the purpose of the report -- to see how tax revenue projections are looking compared to what state agencies say they want and need.

Nothing’s changed about the methodology behind the shortfall projections.

The only thing that’s changed is Walker’s tune.

He still talks up the 2010 figures as if describing a budget-balancing miracle, but now dismisses their 2014 version as a big nothing.

This merits a Full Flop.


More on Scott Walker

For profiles and stories on Scott Walker and 2016 presidential politics, go to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel's Scott Walker page.

Our Sources

Fox News, Bret Baier interview with Gov. Walker, aired Feb. 6, 2015

State Department of Administration, division of executive budget and finance, Agency Budget Requests and Revenue Estimates report, FY 2016 and FY 2017, Nov. 20, 2014

Interview with Bob Lang, Legislative Fiscal Bureau director, Feb. 6, 2015

PolitiFact Wisconsin and Milwaukee Journal Sentinel stories as noted

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Dave Umhoefer

Did Scott Walker flip-flop on how budget shortfalls are measured??

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up