Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
File this under the category of be careful what you wish for.
Four years ago, Qatar emerged triumphant when the Fédération Internationale de Football Association, better known as FIFA, voted to hold the 2022 World Cup in the oil and gas rich emirate. Qatar’s bid involved massive construction plans for new stadiums, rail lines and virtually an entire new city. It would be the marquee event for a country that aims to transform itself into an intercontinental crossroads.
But controversy followed almost as soon as the decision was announced. With daytime temperatures hitting 120 degrees there has been talk of shifting the games from the summer to the winter. Then last year, a newspaper exposé led to an official investigation that Qatar paid million dollar bribes to win FIFA approval. A member of the FIFA Executive Committee called the Qatar pick a "blatant mistake."
Qatar’s treatment of foreign workers also has come into the spotlight. Amnesty International and other human rights groups report rampant abuse in the construction industry.
ESPN host Jeremy Schaap went to Doha to investigate allegations of laborers from India, Nepal and elsewhere who find themselves toiling in brutal heat, dying in accidents and locked into jobs with no way to get back home because their passports had been confiscated.
"We're talking about a country that can afford to do better," Schaap said on MSNBC’s All In with Chris Hayes. Schaap noted that per capita, Qatar is the richest nation in the world.
"Qataris don't really work. They don't have to work," Schaap said, claiming that the Qatari government offers generous benefits for the unemployed.
Schaap’s statement that Qataris "don’t really work" struck us as worth learning more about.
We asked Schaap to clarify. In his response, he dialed down his rhetoric.
"I should have said as laborers on construction sites," Schaap told PunditFact. He added that 94 percent of those workers are foreign -- a fact that came up during his MSNBC interview. This led to a further qualification of the more sweeping statement he made on air.
"It's not quite ‘no Qataris’," he said.
Indeed, official statistics show that most Qataris 15 years old and up are employed. According to the CIA’s World Factbook, the country has the second lowest unemployment rate in the world, about 0.3 percent. (Definitions of employment might matter here. Cambodia comes in first and its economy is hardly as robust as Qatar’s.)
According to the latest figures from the government of Qatar itself, a total of 82,000 Qataris are working out of a total population estimated at 278,000. (Oddly, the government doesn’t provide population data by nationality.) That represents 68 percent of men over the age of 15 and 35 percent of women. A large fraction of women are listed as "homemakers" and thus not employed. The most common job for men is clerk. The most common job for women is professional.
Schaap does have a point that the government takes good care of its ciitizens. In 2008, nearly 90 percent of Qataris worked in public-sector jobs. A huge factor here is the state-owned petroleum industry. Oil exports netted the government over $55 billion in 2012 and hydrocarbons represent about 60 percent of the nation's GDP. A new college graduate with no experience can expect a job paying $65,000 or more.
The country has more than 1.25 million foreign workers. About 700,000 of them are men working in trades or industrial facilities. On average, they work about 50 hours per week. That’s 10 hours more each week than the average Qatari worker.
All this in a country the size of Connecticut.
Following a tough assessment from the UN’s International Labor Organization, Qatari officials proposed a number of labor reforms. There would be higher penalties for employers who confiscate the passports of foreign workers and an end to a system of exit permits that gave employers control over who could leave the country. International advocacy groups called this a step in the right direction but said the proposed changes didn’t go far enough and violators might never be punished.
Schaap said Qataris "don’t really work." Schaap later clarified his statement, saying he should have specified that he was thinking of work on construction sites, and even with that caveat, his claim went a bit too far.
We rate statements based on what was said on air. In that regard, official reports show that most Qataris of working age do work and hold a variety of jobs. In one way or another, the government provides nearly all these jobs but people still need to show up to get paid. A small fraction of the construction workforce is Qatari. The risks for foreign workers are real, but that is separate from Schaap’s assertion.
We rate the claim False.
MSNBC, All In with Chris Hayes, May 28, 2014
Central Intelligence Agency, World Fact Book - Qatar
Qatar Statistics Authority, Unemployment rate has dropped by 3.1% in the State of Qatar, 2012
Qatar Statistics Authority, Employed persons (15 years & above) and average work hours by nationality, sex & occupation, 2012
BQDoha.com, Population of Qatar, Dec. 18, 2013
Arab Center for Research and Policy Studies, Discrepancies in Public and Private Sector Pay in Jordan, Qatar and the UAE, March 5, 2012
U.S. Energy Information Administration, Qatar, Jan. 30, 2014
Christian Science Monitor, Qatar's youths: Why protest? We have it pretty great, July 10, 2013
Telegraph, World Cup 2022 investigation: demands to strip Qatar of World Cup, March 18, 2014
Guardian, Qatar 2022 puts Fifa's reputation on the line, Sept. 25, 2013
Guardian, UN agency criticises Qatar over migrant workers' rights, March 31, 2014
CNN, Qatar World Cup 2022: FIFA reformer calls for vote rerun, March 20, 2014
Amnesty International, Qatar: End corporate exploitation of migrant construction workers, Nov. 17, 2013
FIFA, FIFA and BWI discuss Qatar labour rights and working conditions, March 18, 2014
Bloomberg, Qatar Alters Laws as Workers Die on Pre-World Cup Projects, May 14, 2014
Fox Sports, A timeline of the farce that has 2022 Qatar World Cup and summer-winter debate, Sept. 12, 2013
Human Rights Watch, Dispatches: Qatar’s Labor Reforms Fall Short, Feb. 11, 2014
Wall Street Journal, Qatar Pledges Labor Reform, But Rights Groups Say It Falls Short, May 15, 2014
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.