Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
The Bureau of Labor and Industries enforces Oregonians’ civil rights in housing and employment. Last week, Labor Commissioner Brad Avakian took to public radio to talk about his role in enforcing federal fair housing laws.
"We do about 300 investigations a year into housing discrimination and in recent years have put about $150,000 of damages into the pockets of individuals who have been treated unfairly," he said.
That seemed easy enough to check. We searched online the words Avakian, housing and complaints, and found an April 2010 press release in which his office claimed investigating more than 200 complaints since May 2008. Two hundred in two years versus 300 a year? We asked the commissioner’s office to reconcile.
Bob Estabrook, the commissioner’s spokesman, owned up to the discrepancy right away. He said the commissioner misspoke. An August 2011 check found roughly 350 housing investigations since May 2008, when BOLI was reauthorized to investigate federal housing claims. That comes out to more than 100 complaints a year, not the 300 a year claimed.
As for the money, Estabrook said he couldn’t release dates or other details, because some of the information may be confidential or not easily available. But he said 67 complaints were settled privately, between the parties, or settled at agency prompting.
Of the 67 cases, 31 included monetary exchanges totaling almost $160,000. The amounts ranged from $500 to $20,000. It’s not all technically "damages," but it is money that probably would not have gone to complainants without intervention by the agency, he said.
PolitiFact Oregon can’t verify the dollar amounts, but we can rule on -- and tell you more about -- the number of cases.
A BOLI database shared with The Oregonian shows 339 housing cases through early August 2011. Of those:
- There were 77 complaints in calendar year 2008.
- There were 88 complaints in 2009.
- There were 108 complaints in 2010.
- There were 66 complaints through early August 2011.
- There are 75 cases currently under investigation.
- There were 141 cases closed with no substantial evidence of discrimination.
Avakian’s claim of 300 a year is clearly inaccurate. We give his office points for admitting he misspoke -- that’s a good thing in a politician -- and under some circumstances that might cause us to ignore the flub.
But Avakian is in a special election race for Congress, making his record as a state official that much more important for voters to understand. To correct that record, we rate the statement False.
Labor Commissioner Brad Avakian, "BOLI Resumes Investigation of Fair Housing Complaints," July 9, 2008
Labor Commissioner Brad Avakian, "Governor Proclaims April to be Fair Housing Month in Oregon," April 1, 2010
Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries, housing complaint database
Interview with and emails from Bob Estabrook, Sept. 13-14, 2011
Oregon Legislative Fiscal Office, "Analysis of the 2011-13 Current Service Level - Consumer and Business Services,"
The Oregonian, "Portland housing audit finds discrimination in 64 percent of tests; city has yet to act against landlords," May 9, 2011
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.