Get PolitiFact in your inbox.
Republicans don't yet have a declared candidate to challenge incumbent Sen. Sherrod Brown in 2012, but that hasn't stopped them from opening the campaign.
The National Republican Senatorial Committee (NRSC), which assists election efforts, made that clear by issuing a series of news releases after Brown spoke at a January luncheon of the Akron Roundtable.
One release, citing coverage in the Akron Beacon Journal, went after the senator "in light of Brown’s admission that his $787 billion stimulus law failed, and his sudden election-cycle flip-flop to demand more tax cuts."
"After specifically attacking Republicans for wanting to lower Americans' taxes, Brown now claims that his stimulus bill 'didn't do enough' to lower taxes," the NRSC’s Chris Bond said.
Listening to the talk and reading the Beacon Journal story, however, we did not hear the same "admission." Here is what the story said:
"Brown defended the federal government's fiscal actions during the Great Recession, saying it was necessary to borrow nearly $1.5 trillion to rescue and stimulate the economy and prevent a global collapse. The efforts also helped save major manufacturers such as General Motors and Chrysler, he said.
"The subsequent $787 billion Recovery Act that passed in early 2009 didn't do enough, particularly with tax cuts, to get people to spend more or build public confidence in the economy, he said.
"But the federal government's investments in domestic automakers helped tremendously, Brown said, with the economy now growing and adding jobs.
"If the government hadn't acted, the state would have been in much worse shape, Brown said."
He did not say the stimulus failed. He said it was not large enough, which he has said consistently.
As for tax reductions, Brown said the tax cuts "didn’t do what they should have. They weren’t large enough, as it turned out, to get people to spend more, they weren’t public enough to help it build public confidence in our economy."
In explanation, Brown’s office cited a New York Times/CBS News Poll of September 2010, which found that fewer than one in 10 respondents knew that the stimulus had lowered taxes for most Americans, giving typical families an extra $65 a month.
Few people noticed the tax cut because, instead of getting rebate checks, taxpayers had less money withheld from their paychecks, Brown’s staff said. Increases in health-insurance deductions, increases in state taxes in 30 states and cutbacks in business also reduced take-home pay.
But what about the claim that Brown specifically attacked Republicans for wanting to lower Americans' taxes?
Brown was a vocal opponent of extending the Bush tax cuts for the wealthiest 2 percent of taxpayers, which he said have failed to stimulate the economy. He did vote in favor of their extension last December, but said it was only because the bill extended tax reductions for the middle class and included billions of dollars in unemployment benefits.
So where does the NRSC land on the Truth-O-Meter?
- Brown didn’t say that the stimulus package failed.
- The claim that the senator attacked Republicans for wanting to lower Americans’ taxes has an element of truth to it, but an important fact that is missing is that his opposition dealt with extending the Bush tax cuts for the highest wage earners and had nothing to do with the stimulus package.
- The claim that Brown said the stimulus bill didn't do enough to lower taxes also has an element of truth to it. Brown said tax cuts in the stimulus didn’t get people to spend more, and weren’t public enough to build public confidence in the economy.
That’s why we rate the statement as Half True.
National Republican Senatorial Committee, news release: "Senator Sherrod Brown's Stimulus Comments," Feb. 1, 2011
Akron Beacon Journal, "Sen. Brown touts manufacturing as key to recovery," Jan. 31, 2011
Akron Roundtable, Sen. Sherrod Brown, Jan. 31, 2011
E-mail and interview, Meghan Dubyak, communications director for Brown, Feb. 22-23, 2011
New York Times, "From Obama, The Tax Cut Nobody Heard Of," Oct. 18, 2010
CNN, "Stimulus package en route to Obama’s desk," Feb. 14, 2009
Columbus Dispatch, "Brown grits his teeth, votes to extend tax cuts for all," Dec. 16, 2010
CNN, "CNN Newsroom," aired Jan. 28, 2009
Sen. Sherrod Brown, "February 2009 Wrap Up"
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.