Get PolitiFact in your inbox.
Opponents of Georgia’s new immigration crackdown law are drawing ugly comparisons between it and infamous chapters of civil rights history.
Some are comparing the effects of House Bill 87 to segregation, saying it will turn Hispanics into second-class citizens. Former state Senate Minority Leader Robert Brown, a Democrat who recently resigned to run for mayor of Macon, hearkened back to Reconstruction in a June 2 news release.
"Georgia leaders should not attempt to satisfy Agribusiness interests by finding ways to selectively enforce what I am now calling the Brown Codes (HB 87), because of its similarity to the Black Codes passed in the 1800s," Brown said.
Southern states passed the "Black Codes" after the Civil War to force freed slaves back to the plantations. Is Georgia’s HB 87 similar to them?
PolitiFact has ruled on race-tinged analogies before. Democratic U.S. Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz of Florida said that Republican support for requirements that voters show ID cards at the polls means they "want to literally drag us all the way back to Jim Crow laws."
False, we ruled. Although the law could disenfranchise a fraction of minority voters, it would not return the U.S. to Jim Crow.
Closer to home, HB 87’s more controversial provisions give law enforcement officers more leeway to check the immigration status of people they think violated the law. They also prohibit citizens from harboring, transporting or encouraging illegal immigrants to come into the state under certain circumstances.
On Monday, U.S. District Judge Thomas Thrash granted a request for a preliminary injunction that keeps key parts of HB 87 from going into effect.
We asked Brown to explain his "Brown Codes" remark. He said workers toil in punishing heat for "subminimum wages" in conditions amounting to "indentured servitude." (These claims are outside the scope of our inquiry.)
HB 87 intensifies this inequality, Brown said. It allows Hispanics to be singled out for their ethnicity and scares workers from complaining about poor working conditions for fear of deportation.
"Obviously, it’s not exactly the same [as the Black Codes]. It’s just as harsh, relative to the times. This is the 21st century," Brown said.
We consulted a half-dozen historians to check Brown’s claim.
The Black Codes are different from Jim Crow legislation, which segregated blacks and whites. Enacted in former slave states right after the Civil War, the Black Codes tried to force ex-slaves back to their masters.
Unemployed blacks could be arrested as vagrants and hired out to people willing to pay their criminal fines. Blacks who quit their jobs could be arrested and returned to their old bosses, much like runaway slaves. Orphans or children whose parents could not support them could be apprenticed to a master.
All the experts we interviewed found big holes in Brown’s analogy.
The biggest was this one: The Black Codes aimed to keep freed slaves on their plantations. Georgia’s immigration law pressures illegal immigrants to leave the state. Many of the state’s farmers say illegal immigrants are fleeing in droves.
This result appears to match HB 87’s apparent intent, which is "to create such a climate of hostility, fear, mistrust and insecurity that all illegal aliens will leave Georgia," Thrash ruled.
There are other glaring differences between the Black Codes and Georgia’s law. Immigrants who come to the U.S. illegally to work are here by choice. Obviously, former slaves had no choice.
Swarthmore College professor Richard M. Valelly, an expert on Reconstruction, noted that illegal immigrants aren’t in danger of being re-enslaved. They’re at risk of deportation.
"That's draconian ... but there's a big difference between de facto re-enslavement ... and being sucked into a system that regulates movement across borders," Valelly said.
Although scholars agree that the Black Codes and Georgia’s new immigration law are very different, each one we interviewed saw one similarity.
The Black Codes stigmatized blacks. Georgia’s law stigmatizes illegal immigrants, Columbia University professor Eric Foner said. He is the author of "Reconstruction: America's Unfinished Revolution, 1863-1877," a well-regarded history of the era.
"These laws will probably tend to further solidify an underclass who exist outside of the protection of the law," said Michael W. Fitzgerald, a history professor at St. Olaf College in Minnesota who has written about the Reconstruction.
University of Georgia professor James C. Cobb, an expert on Southern history, was equally critical. He said HB 87, like the Black Codes, allows for discrimination.
"Under the new immigration bill, people who are, in fact, citizens or eligible for certain legal protections are now subject to having their rights violated simply on the basis of their racial appearance," Cobb said.
Still, we think Brown’s comparison between Georgia’s new immigration crackdown and the Black Codes is fatally flawed.
The Black Codes forced freed slaves back to the fields of their masters. HB 87 chases illegal immigrants out of the state.
Illegal immigrant workers come here by choice. Slaves were forced here. And the deportation illegal immigrants face is a far cry from the cruelty of re-enslavement.
Both laws do single out groups for stigmatization, but that won’t improve Brown’s rating by much. The difference between the Black Codes and Georgia’s new immigration law is so vast it gives an inaccurate impression.
We therefore rule Brown’s statement False.
News release, Senate Press Office, "Sen. Brown calls for repeal of HB 87," June 2, 2011
PolitiFact.com, "Debbie Wasserman Schultz compares GOP-backed voting bills to Jim Crow," June 5, 2011
Georgia Latino Alliance for Human Rights, etc. al., v. Nathan Deal, order for preliminary injunction, June 27, 2011
Georgia Black Codes, accessed June 27, 2011
Mississippi Black Codes, accessed June 27, 2011
Georgia General Assembly, House Bill 87, accessed June 27, 2011
Interview, state Sen. Robert Brown, June 20, 2011
Interview, Eric Foner, DeWitt Clinton Professor of History, Columbia University, June 21, 2011
Email interview, James C. Cobb, Spalding Distinguished Research Professor, University of Georgia, June 28, 2011
Email interview, Randall Miller, professor of history, Saint Joseph's University, June 27, 2011
Email interview, Paul A. Cimbala, professor, history department, Fordham University, June 27, 2011
Email interview, Richard M. Valelly, political science professor, Swarthmore College, June 20, 2011
Email interview, Michael Fitzgerald, history professor, St. Olaf College, June 20, 2011
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.