Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
The Department of Homeland Security did not confirm the existence of an “intelligence report” about Venezuela sending criminals to the southern U.S. border. The claim originated with a Breitbart News article that cited an unnamed Customs and Border Protection source.
PolitiFact was unable to find any evidence of the report’s existence or any proof that Venezuela is taking those actions.
Republicans have praised Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis’ recent decision to use taxpayer money to fly two planes of Venezuelan asylum seekers from Texas to Florida to Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts.
Meanwhile, in Congress, some GOP lawmakers have raised flags about Venezuelan immigrants at the southern border, citing an alleged Department of Homeland Security report saying the Venezuelan government is sending prisoners to the southern U.S. border.
"DHS confirms that Venezuela empties prisons and sends violent criminals to our southern border," Rep. Troy Nehls, R-Texas, tweeted on Sept. 18.
🚨BREAKING🚨— Congressman Troy Nehls (@RepTroyNehls) September 18, 2022
DHS confirms that Venezuela empties prisons and sends violent criminals to our southern border.
President Trump warned us about this years ago.
A few days later, 13 Republican members of Congress joined Nehls in sending a letter to Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, requesting more information on "the intelligence report." The letter claims DHS sent such a report to Border Patrol agents instructing them to "look for violent criminals from Venezuela among the migrant caravans heading towards the U.S.-Mexico border."
The lawmakers’ letter says, "It has been widely reported that the Venezuelan regime, under the control of Nicolás Maduro Moros, is deliberately releasing violent prisoners early, including inmates convicted of ‘murder, rape, and extortion,’ and pushing them to join caravans heading to the United States."
However, it cites only one article, from the politically conservative website Breitbart News. A Fox News story about this DHS report cites the same Breitbart article.
🚨 I sent a letter with 13 of my @HouseGOP colleagues to @SecMayorkas demanding answers about Venezuela releasing violent prisoners early and pushing them to join caravans heading towards our southern border.— Congressman Troy Nehls (@RepTroyNehls) September 22, 2022
We need transparency and accountability from this administration. pic.twitter.com/zqx4yCtEP6
Breitbart’s story relies on "a source within" Customs and Border Protection who is "not authorized to speak to the media." The story vaguely describes the DHS report. Other conservative information outlets such as The Epoch Times and The Center Square have also cited Breitbart’s article.
PolitiFact reached out to Nehls’ office asking for evidence and a copy of the report.
"Prove him wrong," Taylor Hulsey, Nehl’s communications director responded.
PolitiFact did not find any evidence supporting the claim.
PolitiFact searched the websites of the DHS Office of the Inspector General, DHS and CBP and found no public reports or mentions of Venezuela’s government releasing prisoners and sending them to the U.S.
We also reached out directly to DHS and CBP asking whether the report existed and whether we could have a copy. The department and agency did not provide an on-the-record response confirming or denying the report’s existence.
CBP publishes data on how many people with criminal convictions or who are wanted by law enforcement have encounters with immigration officials at U.S. borders. Criminals encountered are not let into the country, "absent extenuating circumstances," according to the agency.
CBP reports that so far in fiscal year 2022, which ends Sept. 30, officers at ports of entry have encountered more than 15,500 foreign nationals who have criminal convictions or are wanted by law enforcement. At parts of the border that are not ports of entry, nearly 11,000 meeting that description have been encountered by Border Patrol.
That data does not provide a breakdown by nationality. Previous presidential administrations, including Donald Trump’s, have also published data on encounters of criminal noncitizens at U.S. borders.
The number of Venezuelans trying to enter the United States at the southern border has risen in the past year. Border Patrol has encountered Venezuelan immigrants more than 155,000 times in fiscal year 2022, compared with 50,000 in fiscal year 2021. Encounters data counts the number of events, not the number of unique people.
Unlike immigrants of other nationalities, Venezuelans who arrive at the U.S. southern border aren’t expelled through a public health policy that's in place to mitigate the spread of COVID-19. This is because of Venezuela’s tense diplomatic relations with the U.S.
The U.S. broke diplomatic relations with Venezuela and closed its embassy in 2019 after what it described as a fraudulent presidential election. The U.S. recognizes the opposition leader Juan Guaidó as Venezuela’s interim president, but President Nicolás Maduro remains in power.
Venezuelans without criminal convictions and who aren’t wanted by law enforcement are allowed in the U.S. and can apply for protections afforded under immigration law. Border Patrol checks the immigrants’ backgrounds and takes their fingerprints and other biometric information. Agents question them and decide whether they have a reasonable fear of returning to their home country. If they do, they can seek asylum in the U.S.
People allowed to apply for asylum are detained or released while they await their court proceedings.
Venezuela is undergoing a yearslong humanitarian crisis marked by rampant inflation, human rights abuses and dwindling food and supplies. As a result, more than 6 million Venezuelans have left the country and become refugees elsewhere, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees said.
Human Rights Watch describes Venezuela’s authoritarian government as lacking transparency. The country is ranked "not free," the worst rating given by Freedom House, a nonprofit that advocates for democracy, in its annual review of political rights and civil liberties. In its press freedom index, Reporters Without Borders, ranked Venezuela as "not free," its lowest designation.
PolitiFact reached out to Venezuela’s foreign ministry about the claim that its government is sending prisoners to the U.S. southern border, but didn’t hear back.
PolitiFact also did not find coverage about this report or its content in Spanish-language or Venezuelan media.
Email exchange, DHS spokesperson, Sept. 23, 2022
Email exchange, Taylor Hulsey, Communications Director for Rep. Troy Nehls, Sept. 21, 2022
Email exchange, Dant Bahar, Nonresident Senior Fellow for Global Economy and Development at the Cato Institute, Sept. 27, 2022
Congressman Troy Nehls, tweet, Sept. 18, 2022
PolitiFact, What we know about DeSantis flying migrants to Martha's Vineyard, Sept. 16, 2022
Congressman Troy Nehls, Rep. Nehls Asks Mayorkas to Secure Borders from Released Venezuelan Prisoners Among Caravans, Sept. 23, 2022
Breitbart, EXCLUSIVE: Venezuela Empties Prisons, Sends Violent Criminals to U.S. Border, Says DHS Report, Sept. 18, 2022
Fox News, House Republicans sound alarm over report Venezuela is sending violent criminals to US border, Sept. 22, 2022
Office of Inspector General, Press Releases, accessed Sept. 26, 2022
DHS, News, accessed Sept. 26, 2022
CBP, Media Releases, accessed Sept. 26, 2022
CBP, Nationwide Encounters, accessed Sept. 26, 2022
PolitiFact, Clarifying the nuances in immigration law after DeSantis sent migrants to Martha’s Vineyard, Sept. 23, 2022
UNHCR, Venezuela situation, accessed Sept. 26, 2022
CNN, DeSantis gets standing ovation from GOP voters after flying migrants to Martha’s Vineyard, Sept. 18, 2022
CBP, CBP Enforcement Statistics Fiscal Year 2022, accessed Sept. 27, 2022
TRAC, Most Border Patrol Apprehensions are for Repeat Crossers, But Agency Data Doesn’t Yet Provide the Full Picture, Sept. 9, 2022
CBP, Inadmissibility and Waivers, accessed Sept. 27, 2022
Congressional Research Service, Expedited Removal of Aliens: Legal Framework, Oct. 8, 2019
Freedom House, Venezuela, accessed Sept. 28, 2022
Human Rights Watch, Venezuela Events of 2021, accessed Sept. 28, 2022