Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo said it’s been hard to convince upstate lawmakers to support higher taxes on the wealthy.
That’s even the case with lawmakers whose districts don’t have any millionaires, he said.
"Many of the Senate and Assembly districts, they don't have a millionaire upstate," Cuomo said. "So, it would affect literally no one. But they're against it because it's their basic philosophy as I mentioned."
New York state taxes wealthy earners at a higher rate. Republicans have said they oppose the higher rate for the wealthy. But during last year’s state budget deal, lawmakers agreed to extend the higher rate until the end of 2019.
Since then, high-income earners lost the option to deduct more than $10,000 in state income tax as part of the federal tax law passed by Congress. So Cuomo wants to change the state tax code so wealthy residents can continue those deductions.
Is he right that there are few millionaires upstate?
How many millionaires live upstate?
Nine counties north of Westchester County had fewer than 10 people who earned more than $1 million in 2014, according to the latest data from the state Department of Tax and Finance. The state won’t disclose the precise number of millionaires in a county where there are fewer than 10.
The nine counties are rural: Schoharie, Montgomery, Hamilton, Lewis, Cortland, Schuyler, Seneca, Yates, and Orleans counties.
There were more than 3,900 millionaires reported in the other 44 counties of upstate New York. Erie County had the most millionaires of any upstate county with 704.
What about Senate and Assembly districts?
It gets more complicated when talking about Senate and Assembly districts. Some districts follow county borders while others include parts of multiple counties. A state Department of Tax and Finance spokesperson said the agency does not track the number of millionaires by Assembly or Senate district.
That makes it impossible to verify what Cuomo said.
We can, however, look at those whose districts are in the nine counties with fewer than 10 millionaires.
In the State Assembly, 10 districts include either all or part of those counties. Five of those lawmakers also represent an entire county where millionaires live, so we know they have constituents who are millionaires. The other five Assembly members represent parts of multiple counties and therefore may not represent a millionaire.
In the Senate, seven lawmakers represent a county with less than ten millionaires. Six of those Senators also represent an entire county where millionaires live. Sen. Joseph Griffo, R-Rome, is the exception. He represents all of Lewis County, but only part of Oneida and St. Lawrence counties. Oneida County is home to 89 millionaires. St. Lawrence County has 10 millionaires. Lewis County is one of the nine counties without a reported number of millionaires.
Cuomo said "many of the Senate and Assembly districts, they don't have a millionaire upstate."
The state does not track the number of millionaires by Senate or Assembly district, but they do report how many live in each county. But district lines do not always line up with counties, making it imposible to show which lawmakers represent millionaires and which do not, if any.
It seems unlikely Cuomo's statement is true, but without the data to indicate one way or the other, we’re not making a ruling.
Email conversation with James Gazzale, spokesperson for the state Department of Taxation and Finance
Data obtained from the state Department of Taxation and Finance
Assembly and Senate district maps obtained through the Legislative Task Force on Demographic Research and Reapportionment