Get PolitiFact in your inbox.

By Ryan Kelly October 22, 2007

Many, but not "every"

During a Republican debate in Orlando, Fla., on Oct. 21, Rep. Tom Tancredo boasted about his high ratings from conservative groups. "The American Taxpayers Union, for one, gives me the highest rating; the American Conservative Union, highest rating of anybody running for president of the United States; an A rating from the National Right to Life; an A rating from every organization -- every conservative organization that gives ratings to those of us who are here on this stage."

Tancredo consistently ranks near the top of Republicans when measured by conservative organizations, oftentimes earning an "A" grade. The American Conservative Union indeed gives him the highest rating -- last year alone and by lifetime average -- of any presidential candidate.

Still, Tancredo manages to be a bit misleading about his credentials when claiming the "highest" rating from other groups or that "every conservative organization" has given him an "A" rating.

First- there is not, to our knowledge, an organization called the "American Taxpayers Union." Since Rep. Tancredo cites his "A" grade from the "National Taxpayers Union" on his website, we'll assume he meant them. While he did garner an "A" from the National Taxpayers Union, it wasn't the highest grade among the Republicans seeking the presidency.

Tancredo's 2006 score was 76%, an "A." His average score over the past 8 years was 78.4%. Rep. Ron Paul has him beat on both counts, with a 2006 score of 84% and an average of 86.9% over the past 10 years.

Featured Fact-check

On Tancredo's website, there's a voting record scorecard showing his receipt of "A" grades from seven conservative organizations. Omitted from that list, however, is the powerful, fiscally conservative group, The Club for Growth.

The Club for Growth, known for mounting serious primary challenges against Republican incumbents it feel aren't conservative enough, has been keeping tabs on Members of Congress since 2005, said Club for Growth spokesperson Nachama Soloveichik. Tancredo's score, on a scale of 0-100, was an 88 in 2005 and an 80 in 2006.

Soloveichik tells PolitiFact that although they haven't translated the numerical scores into letter grades, members must score a 90 or above to earn their "Defender of Economic Freedom Award," and Tancredo fell short of that. So overall, we give his claim a Mostly True.


Our Sources

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Ryan Kelly

Many, but not "every"

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up