Wisconsin senator wrong to attribute rising COVID cases to testing

After an extended period of mostly positive trends, COVID-19 is making a resurgence in America.

At least 21 states were pausing reopening plans or taking new steps to limit the virus as of June 30, USA TODAY reported. In Wisconsin, new cases rose noticeably the last two weeks of June after falling steadily in the first half of the month.

The reversal has led to an increased push for mask usage and other measures to limit the spread.

But one Wisconsin lawmaker said a step like mandating masks isn't needed, pointing in part to the number of tests being conducted.

"The cases are going up, but it's because the testing is going up," Sen. Chris Kapenga, R-Delafield, said in an interview with WISN-TV on June 29, 2020. "The hospitalization rate is still within the comfort zone of every single hospital."

We’ll focus on the first part of this phrase, since the interplay of testing and case trends is critical to understanding what the virus is doing in our state.

Essentially, Kapenga is blaming the increase only on the volume of tests.

Here’s why that’s wrong.

Wisconsin isn’t seeing a surge as significant as some states in the South, but the cases are clearly rising.

The seven-day average of new cases was around 270 in mid-June, but it rose to more than 400 by late June when Kapenga made his statement. The seven-day average is the best judge of general trends since it smooths out the daily stats, which can jump up and down for a variety of reasons.

But Kapenga’s reasoning fails on two fronts.

First, this ignores the more detailed stats that show what is actually driving the increase.

Featured Fact-check

Instagram posts

stated on November 7, 2024 in Instagram posts

“2,038 suicides have been reported (Nov. 6) following Donald Trump’s election win.”

Experts say people here are letting their guard down, particularly residents in their 20s who went from 20% of the state’s positive tests before June 22 to 40% after that date. They point to the increasing willingness — in that age group and others — to get together at bars, parties and other social events. 

Contact tracing has confirmed these get-togethers as an increasingly common source of COVID-19 infections. The trend has spurred officials in Madison to order bars to close again.

Second, his basic premise is flat wrong — testing isn’t going up.

The seven-day average of daily tests in Wisconsin peaked at 12,000 on June 9 and has marched steadily downward since. The average was just over 9,000 on June 29 when Kapenga made his claim.

Throughout May, new cases and testing volume both generally rose. But the trends separated after that. And in the last half of June new cases rose as testing dropped.

The seven-day average of daily tests in Wisconsin peaked at 12,000 on June 9 and has marched steadily downward since. The average was just over 9,000 on June 29 when Kapenga made his claim.

Addressing rising COVID-19 case counts in Wisconsin, Kapenga said measures like mandatory mask use aren’t necessary because cases are rising due to increased testing.

That’s flat wrong.

Experts say there are clear drivers to the recent uptick, like residents in their 20s largely ignoring social distancing. So Kapenga’s attempt to minimize the trend to a result of testing frequency is misguided.

Most notably, Kapenga’s core premise is simply not accurate. Testing was dropping, not rising, in late June as cases rose. He defended his claim as a "generality," but it’s a generality that hasn’t been true since May.

We rate this False.