Get PolitiFact in your inbox.
Did a ‘traffic court judge’ try to remove Trump from the Illinois primary ballot? No
If Your Time is short
-
Cook County Circuit Judge Tracie R. Porter previously served in the traffic division. But her current role in the county division encompasses a broad scope of cases.
-
Our mission: Help you be an informed participant in democracy. Learn more.
Does a traffic court judge have the power to remove a presidential candidate from a primary ballot?
On Feb. 28, Cook County Circuit Judge Tracie R. Porter issued a ruling to remove former President Donald Trump from the 2024 ballot for Illinois’ March 19 primary. The ruling was put on hold to give Trump’s team time to appeal — and the case will not proceed after the Supreme Court halted a similar effort in Colorado.
Some social media users are questioning her ability to make such a decision.
"The ‘Judge’ who took Trump off the ballot in Illinois is a traffic court judge who presides over ‘minor traffic violations and Class A Misdemeanors,’" read a Feb. 29 Instagram post by Ryan Fournier, a conservative commentator. "A traffic court judge … You can’t make this up."
(Screenshot from Instagram)
This post was flagged as part of Meta’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram.)
Although Porter previously served in the traffic division, her current role in the county division encompasses a broader scope of cases.
Porter won a 2022 election to become a Cook County Circuit judge. According to the Illinois State Constitution, circuit courts have jurisdiction on all matters except those with jurisdiction reserved for the state Supreme Court, namely, General Assembly redistricting and ruling on the governor’s ability to serve or resume office.
Cook County’s Circuit Court has three departments: county, municipal, and juvenile justice and child protection.
Porter is a circuit judge in the court’s county division under the county department. The county division handles the following:
-
Adoption.
Featured Fact-check
-
Name changes.
-
Marriage of minors.
-
Annexation and de-annexation of land to a tax body.
-
Elections.
-
Inheritance taxes.
-
Mental health proceedings.
-
Real estate taxes.
-
Municipal organizations.
-
Orders of protection filed in conjunction with a mental health proceeding.
Porter was previously in the traffic division, according to an archived copy of her page captured Dec. 20, 2022.
The U.S. Supreme Court overturned the Colorado Supreme Court’s ruling that disqualified Trump, effectively halting all efforts, including that of Illinois, to remove him from the ballot.
We rate the claim that an Illinois judge ordered Trump’s removal from the state’s primary ballot while serving as a "traffic court judge" False.
Our Sources
Instagram post (archived), Feb. 29, 2024
CBS News, Judge orders former President Trump removed from Illinois primary ballot, but puts order on hold, Feb. 29, 2024
Forbes, Who Is Tracie Porter? Illinois Judge Removes Trump From Primary Ballot Over Jan. 6., Feb. 29, 2024
Axios, Cook County judge boots Trump from Illinois primary ballot, Feb. 29, 2024
Web Archive copy, Honorable Tracie R. Porter, Circuit Judge, archived on Dec. 20, 2022
CBS News, Illinois effort to keep Trump off ballot is over after U.S. Supreme Court ruling, March 5, 2024
Constitution of the State of Illinois, accessed March 6, 2024
Illinois Courts, Circuit Court, accessed March 6, 2024
Illinois State Board of Elections, Election results for the 2022 General Election, accessed March 6, 2024
Circuit Court of Cook County, Organization of the Circuit Court, accessed March 6, 2024
Circuit Court of Cook County, Honorable Tracie R. Porter, Circuit Judge, accessed March 6, 2024
Circuit Court of Cook County, County Department Overview, accessed March 6, 2024
Circuit Court of Cook County, County Division, accessed March 6, 2024
FactCheck.org, Role of Illinois Circuit Court Judge Misrepresented in Post About Trump’s Removal from Ballot, March 4, 2024
Verify, No, the person who removed Trump from Illinois primary ballot is not a traffic court judge, March 1, 2024
Browse the Truth-O-Meter
More by Loreben Tuquero
Did a ‘traffic court judge’ try to remove Trump from the Illinois primary ballot? No
Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.