The Austin Independent School District board voted to mandate "a pornographic sex education policy that includes instruction on anal sex and how to place a condom on an erect penis."
Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Former Fox News radio host Todd Starnes said Austin ISD's new human sexuality curriculum is "pornographic." Is that true? (Austin American-Statesman).
No, a Texas school district did not adopt pornographic sex ed curriculum
Former Fox News Radio host Todd Starnes said that a school district in Texas is requiring "teaching kids how to have anal sex," after the Austin school district board voted to adopt new sex education curriculum for elementary and middle school students.
In an Oct. 29 post on his website, Starnes described the new curriculum and relied on information from Texas Values, a conservative organization that opposed the new instruction materials.
"In spite of overwhelming opposition from parents and pastors, the district’s trustees voted early Tuesday morning to implement a pornographic sex education policy that includes instruction on anal sex and how to place a condom on an erect penis," he wrote.
This is a largely inaccurate description of the new curriculum. The lessons include instructions on condom use, but they do not include detailed information on anal sex or any pornographic materials.
Starnes did not return a request for comment.
Reviewing the new curriculum
The Austin school board approved new sex education curriculum for elementary and middle school students at the end of October.
The curriculum includes instruction about sexual orientation, gender identity and sexually transmitted diseases for the first time in the district, starting as early as fifth grade. It also includes lessons about healthy relationships, puberty and reproduction, according to the American-Statesman.
Any student in the district can be exempted from participating in some or all of the lessons that fall under the umbrella of "Human Sexuality and Responsibility Curriculum" at the request of a parent or guardian, according to the school district’s policy.
The school board voted unanimously to approve the new curriculum, despite resistance from some conservative organizations, including Texas Values. The board heard public feedback on the issue before voting, and roughly 69% of those who spoke disapproved of the changes, according to the American-Statesman.
Is new curriculum ‘pornographic’?
All of the instructional materials and student handouts for the human sexuality curriculum for third through fifth grades and sixth through eighth grades are available on the school district’s website.
Instruction materials for third through fifth grades include anatomical drawings depicting the internal anatomy of both the male and female reproductive systems. Materials for sixth through eighth grade include drawings of internal and external anatomy for both reproductive systems.
Pornography is defined by Merriam-Webster as "the depiction of erotic behavior (as in pictures or writing) intended to cause sexual excitement." Medical images and educational materials are generally not considered pornography.
Megan Maas, an assistant professor of human development and family studies at Michigan State University, reviewed the new curriculum at the request of PolitiFact Texas and said that it "clearly does not meet the definition of pornography."
"It seems comprehensive enough to give students the language they need to enforce the decisions they want to make around sexual behavior," she said in an email. "Even maintaining abstinence requires comprehensive education so that they have the language and skills to refuse some kinds of sexual behavior (e.g. oral sex), but engage in others (e.g. holding hands)."
Most importantly: Texas law prohibits the distribution or display of "harmful materials" to minors — including pornography.
Does curriculum include instruction on anal sex, condom placement?
The bulk of the sex education lessons for both third through fifth graders and sixth through eighth graders focuses on personal identity and safety as well as identifying and maintaining healthy relationships with family, friends and romantic partners.
There are also lessons on anatomy, puberty and the reproductive system, as well as abstinence, pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases.
Austin is considered an "abstinence-plus" district, meaning that lessons encourage abstinence but also discuss other methods of preventing pregnancy and diseases.
In addition to lessons on abstinence in the new materials, there are also lessons about other contraceptive methods, but those are limited to sixth through eighth grade instruction.
Seventh and eighth grade lessons include information about how to use a male condom, with drawings accompanied by descriptive text. The materials are produced by the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Starnes also said that the new lessons include instruction on anal sex.
Anal sex is mentioned briefly in the curriculum on a list of commonly recognized types of sexual activity and separately as one of the possible vehicles for sexually transmitted diseases.
None of the materials include a detailed description of anal sex or instructions.
Our Ruling
Starnes said that the Austin school board voted to mandate "a pornographic sex education policy that includes instruction on anal sex and how to place a condom on an erect penis."
First of all, parents are allowed to decide whether their children can participate in any sex education instruction offered in the school district. In other words: it is not mandatory.
Also, none of the materials included in the curriculum meet the definition of pornography.
The lesson plans include information about how to use a condom correctly, but they do not include detailed information or instruction about anal sex.
We rate this claim Mostly False.
Our Sources
ToddStarnes.com, Texas School District Mandates Teaching Kids How to Have Anal Sex, Oct. 29, 2019
The Hill, Radio host Todd Starnes out at Fox News, Oct. 2, 2019
Austin American-Statesman, Austin school district approves revised sex ed curriculum, Oct. 29, 2019
Austin American-Statesman, Austin ISD board slated to approve controversial sex ed curriculum, Oct. 25, 2019
Austin Independent School District, Human Sexuality and Responsibility Curriculum at Austin ISD, accessed Nov. 15, 2019
Merriam-Webster, pornography, accessed Nov. 15, 2019
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Male Condom Use, received Nov. 15, 2019
Legal Information Institute, Jacobellis v. Ohio, accessed Nov. 18, 2019
Email interview with Megan Maas, assistant professor of human development and family studies at Michigan State University, Nov. 19, 2019
New York Times, Supreme Court Strikes Down Ban on Virtual Child Pornography, April 16, 2002
Texas Penal Code, Sec. 43.24, accessed Nov. 18, 2019
Browse the Truth-O-Meter
More by Madlin Mekelburg
No, a Texas school district did not adopt pornographic sex ed curriculum
Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.