Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Joy Reid compares deaths in Gaza to 9/11 deaths
Whenever tragedy strikes abroad, pundits often make a point to translate death tolls into dead Americans. The Israeli-Palestinian war is no exception.
On her Aug. 4 Reid Report, Joy Reid called out the United Nations for their inability to stop or temper Israel’s campaign in Gaza. The UN’s "condemnations and expressions of outrage," Reid said, "have done exactly nothing to protect civilians in Gaza."
"So far the war in Gaza has left more than 1,800 Palestinians dead -- the population equivalent to 100 9/11s."
Americans don’t take the name of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks in vain. So we wanted to dig into Reid’s claim: Does her math check out, and is she right to compare the impact of the Palestinian deaths to what Reid defined as the American "population equivalent"?
Reid’s math, and why 9/11s are not a unit
To consider Reid's claim, you need to first know that Reid is essentially looking at the percentage of deaths per population. For one part of the comparison, she's using the population of Gaza, which is pretty straightforward. For the other part of the comparison, she's choosing to use the entire population of the United States. And as we'll show you, that makes all the difference.
Reid's napkin math is relatively straightforward. Roughly 1,800 Palestinians have died out of 1.8 million in Gaza, which equals 0.1 percent of its population. Roughly 3,000 out of 300 million Americans died directly in the Sept. 11 attacks, which works out to 0.001 percent of America’s population.
Compare the two and you get that .1 percent is 100 times 0.001 percent. That’s where "100 9/11s" comes from.
If you use slightly more precise numbers, it doesn’t move the needle that much. The United Nations report issued on Aug. 4, when Reid made her claim, put the number of Palestinian deaths at 1,777 (not more than 1,800, as Reid said), and the CIA estimates Gaza’s population at 1,816,379.
A 10-year memorandum on the Sept. 11 attacks from the National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism puts the number of deaths in the Sept. 11 attacks at 2,997, and the United States Census Bureau population clock puts the U.S. population on Sept. 11, 2011, at 285,558,980.
Using those numbers, we get that Palestine’s death count is the "population equivalent" of 93.22 9/11s when using the entire population of the United States. That's not quite Reid’s 100, but it's not substantially different. But our fractional result does help demonstrate that 9/11s are not a particularly good unit of measurement. It’s unclear what 0.22 of a 9/11 -- or for that matter, 100 9/11s -- would look like.
Impact on society
In his book How Not to Be Wrong: The Power of Mathematical Thinking, University of Wisconsin mathematician Jordan Ellenberg explains how, while occasionally useful, taking population equivalents quickly becomes ridiculous if you apply it to extreme cases.
For example, Ellenberg writes, the 1,074 Israelis killed by Palestinians from 2000-05 works out to 50,000 Americans, but if you scale down instead of up, it loses its punch. The same Israeli death toll, he says, is proportional to only one or two deaths in Tuvalu, a Polynesian island with roughly 1,000 inhabitants.
"When commentators in Israel and Palestine were observing 9/11 when it happened, people weren’t saying, ‘Imagine if 20 Palestinians had been killed,’ " Ellenberg told us.
Similarly, the Palestinian death count from the last couple of weeks is the "population equivalent" of about 1.3 million Chinese, but only one Tuvaluan -- not quite as rhetorically overwhelming as "100 9/11s."
The problem, Ellenburg wrote in a 2006 Slate article, is that our "innate number sense simply doesn’t extend" to extremely small numbers. He uses the example of a Hezbollah bombing of the Israeli city of Haifa, which killed one in every 787,500 Israelis.
"Imagine that it was actually one in 78,750. You just multiplied the scale of the crime tenfold, but can you say sincerely that the two numbers inspire a different reaction? The proportions are just too small to comprehend."
Beyond that, Ellenberg told us, "there’s a huge amount of wiggle room in how you count what population you divide by."
If you use just the population of New York City instead of the entire United States, the Palestinian death count works out to about three 9/11s. And if you limit yourself only to the population of Manhattan, you get less than one 9/11.
It’s not clear which figure is the best choice to put the Palestinian death count in context -- or if any of them are even useful.
Population equivalent, but not morally equivalent
The only "sound ethical theory" that does let you make what philosophers call "inter-personal comparisons" is utilitarianism, Herlitz said, which posits that "all lives are of equal worth. One Palestinian equals one Israeli equals one American, and so on."
So there’s no ethical sense in which 1,800 Palestinian deaths are comparable to "100 9/11s."
Reid, decrying the UN’s failure to temper the rising death counts in Gaza, said, "So far, the war in Gaza has left more than 1,800 Palestinians dead -- the population equivalent to 100 9/11s."
She used a couple of rough estimates, but Reid’s math basically works out for the parameters she set.
The parameters, however, are the problem. Using 9/11s as a unit ignores qualitative differences between the Sept. 11 attack and the Israeli-Palestinian war. It’s also not clear what populations she’s referring to, and while looking at deaths as a proportion of population can be useful, the numbers here are too small for them to mean much.
There are also at least equally valid and different ways to compare deaths as a proportion of population that would produce vastly different results. (Going from 100 9/11s to less than 1 9/11.)
Reid’s statement contains an element of truth but ignores critical facts that would give a different impression. We rate her claim Mostly False.
The Reid Report, Aug. 4, 2014
Email interview with Anders Herlitz, visiting researcher in philosophy at Oxford University, Aug. 7, 2014
Interview with Jordan Ellenberg, math professor at the University of Wisconsin, Aug. 7, 2014
The National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism, "Background Report: 9/11, Ten Years Later," 2011
United States Central Intelligence Agency, "The World Factbook: Country Comparison: Population," July 2014
Mediaite, "MSNBC’s Joy Reid: Israel’s Attacks on Gaza Equal to Hundred 9/11s," Aug. 6, 2014
United Census Bureau, "U.S. and World Population Clock," Aug. 7, 2014
City of New York Department of City Planning, "Current Population Estimates," July 2013
United Nations Relief and Works Agency, "Gaza Emergency: Daily Situation Reports," Aug. 7, 2014
Slate, "Does One Israeli Death Really Equal 47 American Deaths?" July 24, 2006
Washington Post, "Math wiz: Don’t proportionalize deaths of Palestinians and Israelis," Aug. 6, 2014
Read About Our Process
Browse the Truth-O-Meter
More by Derek Tsang
Joy Reid compares deaths in Gaza to 9/11 deaths
Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.