"America’s gun-related homicide rate … would be about the same as Belgium’s if you left out California, Illinois, D.C. and New Jersey, places with some of the strictest gun control laws in the U.S."
Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
If you dropped California, Illinois, New Jersey and Washington, D.C., from the statistics, would the U.S. become as idyllically gun-homicide-free as Belgium? (Photo courtesy Belgium Tourist Office.)
Mike Huckabee says if you cut out just four states, U.S. gun-homicide rate drops to Belgium's level
In a recent Facebook post, former Arkansas Republican Gov. Mike Huckabee used an unusual computation to play down the extent of firearm-related homicides in the United States.
"America’s gun-related homicide rate is nearly 20 times that of other high-income nations," Huckabee said in the Aug. 20 post. "But it would be about the same as Belgium’s if you left out California, Illinois, D.C. and New Jersey: places with some of the strictest gun control laws in the U.S."
For us, this reminded us of the time one of our sources, in a fact-check about a federal budget claim, joked that "I can meet my weight loss goals if I don't count my butt!"
Beyond Huckabee’s curious formula, though, we wondered: Is he right?
Huckabee did not respond to an inquiry for this story placed through his website. We did find that variations of this claim had made the rounds on conservative blogs in the weeks before Huckabee authored his post.
Let’s take a look at both ends of this claim.
The United States
For the U.S. part of the claim, we looked at FBI statistics, which break down data for firearm-related homicides for the nation as a whole as well as by state. Here’s a summary for 2010.
State
Firearm-related homicides
Population
Rate of firearm-related homicides per 100,000 population
California
1,257
37,338,198
3.36
District of Columbia
99
604,912
16.36
Illinois
364
12,841,980
Featured Fact-check
2.83
New Jersey
246
8,799,593
2.79
Four states above
1,966
59,584,684
3.29
U.S. total
8,874
309,330,219
2.87
U.S. minus four states cited by Huckabee
6,908
249,745,535
2.77
So, removing the four states from the equation, as Huckabee did, doesn’t really budge the firearm-related homicide rate for the nation as a whole.
Also, it’s worth noting that the three states Huckabee cited are not among the states with the highest rates of firearm-related deaths. (Washington, D.C., is, but it is an exception because it isn’t a state, but rather a city without suburbs or rural areas.) Several states have firearm-related death rates above 4 per 100,000, including one with strict gun laws (Maryland) but others in which Second Amendment protections are strong (Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri and South Carolina).
Belgium
The most recent figures we could find for Belgium are included in an international data comparison published by the United Nations in 2011.
In 2004, Belgium reported a firearm-related homicide rate of 0.7 per 100,000, which is well below both the United States as a whole and the U.S.-minus-Huckabee’s-four-states figure.
Of course, the data for Belgium is older than the data we used for the United States. However, according to the U.N. compilation, more recent figures for other western European countries show rates even lower than Belgium’s. In 2009 and 2010, the only European countries to post a rate higher than 0.4 per 100,000 were Croatia, Finland, Macedonia, Portugal and Serbia. Every other European nation that reported data during that period was below that threshold. (The Washington Post has published this chart, based on the U.N. data, that compares the advanced industrialized nations by their firearm-related death rate; it shows the U.S. with a much higher rate than any such nation except for Mexico.)
So Huckabee’s comparison isn’t even close.
Our ruling
Huckabee said that "America’s gun-related homicide rate … would be about the same as Belgium’s if you left out California, Illinois, D.C. and New Jersey, places with some of the strictest gun control laws in the U.S."
Not only is this a strange way to analyze the numbers, but it’s not even correct on its own terms. Even after subtracting these four supposedly high-crime jurisdictions, the firearm-related homicide rate in the United States is still about four times higher than the rate in Belgium and the rest of Europe. We rate the claim Pants on Fire.
Our Sources
Mike Huckabee, Facebook post, Aug. 20, 2013
FBI, "Crime in the United States: Data Table 8, Murder Victims by Weapon, 2007–2011," accessed Aug. 28, 2013
FBI, "Crime in the United States: Table 20, Murder by State, Types of Weapons, 2010," accessed Aug. 28, 2013
FBI, "Crime in the United States: Table 4, Crime in the United States by Region, Geographic Division, and State, 2010–2011," accessed Aug. 28, 2013
Washington Post, "Chart: The U.S. has far more gun-related killings than any other developed country," Dec. 14, 2012
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, 2011 Global Study on Homicide (homicides by firearm data), accessed Aug. 28, 2013
Browse the Truth-O-Meter
More by Louis Jacobson
Mike Huckabee says if you cut out just four states, U.S. gun-homicide rate drops to Belgium's level
Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.