Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

Louis Jacobson
By Louis Jacobson December 17, 2024

Biden invested to increase broadband access, but it will take time for Americans to see benefits

President Joe Biden signed legislation allocating billions of federal dollars toward expanding broadband internet access to Americans who didn't already have it, which was one of his 2020 campaign promises.

Biden's biggest effort for expanding internet access was the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment, or BEAD, program, which allocated $42.45 billion to states and territories, much of it to build and deploy communications infrastructure. Funding for the program came through the bipartisan infrastructure bill Biden signed in 2021.

This money has been fully awarded, but in most cases, construction has not yet begun. "It will take years … for all of its projects to be completed," wrote Adie Tomer and Ben Swedberg for the Brookings Institution, a think tank. 

The 2021 American Rescue Plan Act also included a Capital Projects Fund that offered $10 billion to help states, territories, and tribal governments manage the COVID-19 pandemic, including by expanding broadband access.

Carl Roath, with the Mason County, Wash., Public Utility District, helps install broadband internet service to homes in a rural area in 2021. (AP)

Since the first Capital Projects Fund awards were made in June 2022, the fund has "awarded approximately $9.6 billion for broadband, digital technology, and multi-purpose community center projects in all states and the District of Columbia," the Treasury Department's website said. As with the Broadband Equity, Access and Deployment funds, many projects funded by this effort are still being built. 

Because major infrastructure projects take time to plan and execute, these two provisions wouldn't have immediately boosted the percentage of Americans with broadband access during Biden's presidency. But if the percentage grows after Biden leaves office, the legislation he signed would merit credit. 

Another federal broadband program may have produced more immediate gains, because it focused on helping consumers pay for services currently available, rather than by expanding broadband infrastructure.

The Affordable Connectivity Program — another element of the bipartisan infrastructure law — offered eligible households a discount of up to $30 per month toward internet service, or $75 per month on qualifying tribal lands. Eligible households could also get a one-time discount of up to $100 to buy a laptop, desktop, or tablet.

This program enrolled more than 23 million subscribers, according to the Federal Communications Commission. However, funding lapsed in June 2024 because Congress failed to provide additional money. So, any broadband access gains on Biden's watch could be reversed. (Data isn't available yet to know for sure whether a retreat has started.)

Not every American has broadband access, but Census Bureau data shows the share of Americans with broadband subscriptions increased during Biden's presidency.

In 2023, the Census Bureau found that 89.7% of American households had a broadband internet subscription, up from 85.2% in 2020, the year before Biden took office. 

Demographic differences exist. The Pew Research Center found that today, 92% of people with household incomes exceeding $100,000 maintain a home broadband connection and that 88% of households making from $70,000 to $99,999 have one. The rates were lower for households earning from $30,000 to $69,999 (at 78%) and for those earning less than $30,000 (at 57%).

Also, 70% of adults age 65 and older have a broadband connection, which is a lower rate than for younger people. Black and Hispanic household broadband rates trail those of white households by about 10 percentage points. For suburban residents, the rate is 85%, compared with 76% for urban areas and 73% for rural areas.

In their Brookings report, Tomer and Swedberg said Donald Trump's incoming administration could try to claw back some unspent money, but because much of the broadband funding has already been allocated, that would be hard.

Although taking back funding can "make for great political theater," they write, every allocation "has a supportive constituency around the country and on Capitol Hill, and most of them are bipartisan. … What elected official will ask to build less? That's never been winning politics."

Biden's administration allocated funding to increase broadband access to Americans. But it will take time for that investment to materialize, and he won't be in office long enough to see the promise fulfilled.

We rate this Compromise.

Our Sources

U.S. Commerce Department, "Fact Sheet: Department of Commerce's Use of Bipartisan Infrastructure Deal Funding to Help Close the Digital Divide," accessed Dec. 16, 2024

National Telecommunications and Information Administration, Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment, accessed Dec. 16, 2024

U.S. Treasury Department, "Capital Projects Fund," accessed Dec. 16, 2024

Federal Communications Commission, "Affordable Connectivity Program," accessed Dec. 16, 2024

U.S. Census Bureau, "Computer and Internet Use," accessed Dec. 16, 2024

Pew Research Center, "Internet, Broadband Fact Sheet," Nov. 13, 2024

Pew Research Center, "Federal Pandemic Rules Enhance State Flexibility in Deploying Broadband Funds," Aug. 26, 2024

Broadband Breakfast, BEAD page, accessed Dec. 16, 2024

Broadband Breakfast, NTIA page, accessed Dec. 16, 2024

Adie Tomer and Ben Swedberg, "What the Trump administration might mean for the future of the bipartisan infrastructure law," Nov. 25, 2024

Connected Nation, "Program review: Where does BEAD stand three years in?" Sept. 17, 2024

Mia Penner
By Mia Penner July 22, 2024

Affordable Connectivity Program loses funding, puts Biden’s broadband promise in jeopardy

A program to help low-income people pay for broadband ran out of money in May, putting millions of households at risk of losing their internet connections.

The Affordable Connectivity Program, enacted under the 2021 Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, provided an internet service discount of up to $30 per month for most eligible households and up to $75 per month for households on tribal lands. 

A bill to appropriate $7 billion to expand the program through fiscal year 2024 failed to reach a vote in the Republican-led House amid President Joe Biden's repeated calls to restore funding. That puts his promise to expand wireless broadband to every American in jeopardy. 

More than 23 million households — 1 in every 6 — were enrolled in the program but haven't been able to get help since May 31. 

"(The Affordable Connectivity Program) was tremendously successful in that 23 million families subscribed out of a possible 50 million," said Christopher Ali, a  Pennsylvania State University telecommunications professor.  "It was a failure because we failed to renew it, and we also failed to anticipate that it would be so successful."

PolitiFact rated Biden's promise as In the Works after he announced more than $42 billion in June 2023 for states to invest in high-speed internet through the Broadband Equity Access and Deployment program. Although Congress had approved funds for the program as part of the 2021 bipartisan infrastructure law, Biden's announcement included more specific information about how the money would be divided among states and territories. Since then, all eligible states and territories submitted funding proposals, and a number of states have received final approval. The money will likely be disbursed later this year. 

To receive federal funds from the Broadband Equity Access and Deployment program, states must offer a "low-cost broadband service option." Although the Affordable Connectivity Program is a separate initiative, many states incorporated its subsidies into their proposals to meet that requirement.

"Most states have folded ACP into their low cost calculation, so now all of these numbers are off," Ali said.

Analysis from Boston Consulting Group and Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization that conducts media research, found that the Affordable Connectivity Program encouraged internet service providers to expand into lower-income communities by ensuring a customer base and a reliable return on investment.

In a May 2023 House hearing on oversight of the National Telecommunications and Information Administration, Rep. Marc Veasey, D-Texas, asked administrator Alan Davidson whether the Affordable Connectivity Program's expiration would hurt the Broadband Equity Access and Deployment Program. 

"The short answer is that it will," Davidson said. 

A March 2024 Federal Communications Commission report said,"​​More work remains to ensure that all Americans have access to advanced telecommunications capability."

The report also said 24 million Americans lacked broadband access as of 2022. 

Without the Affordable Connectivity Program, that number could rise. A recent Federal Communications Commission survey of program recipients shows that 77% of respondents said losing their discount would disrupt their internet connection by making them change their plan or drop their service.

The Biden administration pledged in May to "continue working to ensure everyone in America can access affordable, reliable high-speed internet."

However, Ali told PolitiFact that the Affordable Connectivity Program's expiration could significantly impede that goal.

"I do not think that with 42 billion given inflation, given the lack of ACP, that we are going to get to 100% connectivity," he said. 

"Broadband is absolutely useless unless people can afford it." 

Congress' failure to renew the Affordable Connectivity Program will significantly hinder Biden's ability to extend high-speed internet access to every American. We rate this promise Stalled. 

Our Sources

Federal Communications Commission, Affordable Connectivity Program, updated June 13, 2024

Congress.gov, H.R.6929 - Affordable Connectivity Program Extension Act of 2024, Jan. 10, 2024

White House, FACT SHEET: President Biden Highlights Commitments to Customers by Internet Service Providers, May 31, 2024

Internetforall.gov, BEAD Initial Proposal Progress Dashboard, updated June 14, 2024

Common Sense Media, Closing the Digital Divide Benefits Everyone, Not Just the Disconnected, 2022

House Committee on Energy and Commerce, Communications and Technology Legislative Hearing, May 23, 2023

Federal Communications Commission, 2024 Section 706 Report, March 18, 2024

Federal Communications Commission, ACP Consumer Survey, December 2023

National Telecommunications and Information Administration, Frequently Asked Questions

and Answers: Low Cost Broadband Service Option, accessed June 20, 2024

Telephone Interview with Christopher Ali, professor of telecommunications at Pennsylvania State University, June 18, 2024

Sevana Wenn
By Sevana Wenn July 6, 2023

Biden announces more than $42 billion for states to invest in high-speed internet

President Joe Biden's administration has allocated $42.45 billion to states and U.S. territories as part of his pledge to increase broadband internet access to all Americans.

"High-speed internet isn't a luxury anymore; it's become an absolute necessity," Biden said June 26 during a White House event promoting the Broadband Equity Access and Deployment program. 

Congress approved funds for the program, alongside other internet access expansion initiatives, as part of the bipartisan infrastructure bill  Biden signed in 2021. The June 26 announcement provided more specific information about how the $42.45 billion will be divided among 50 U.S. states, five territories and the District of Columbia. Eligible entities can use the funds to administer grant programs within their borders, expanding broadband access to underserved communities. 

Once distributed, the funds will further Biden's promise of universal high-speed internet access. 

The allocations range from about $27 million for the U.S. Virgin Islands to $3.3 billion for Texas, according to the Biden administration. Nineteen states received more than $1 billion.

"With these allocations and other Biden administration investments, all 50 states, D.C., and the territories now have the resources to connect every resident and small business to reliable, affordable high-speed internet by 2030," said a White House fact sheet.

States and territories were to begin submitting initial proposals describing how they will administer grant programs July 1. The National Telecommunications and Information Administration will approve these proposals on a rolling basis until Dec. 27. Once a proposal is approved, an eligible entity may receive at least 20% of its allocated funds.

Biden's plan has the potential to provide internet access to some of America's most underserved populations, especially rural and tribal communities. PolitiFact will continue monitoring progress on this pledge; for now, the rating remains In the Works.

Louis Jacobson
By Louis Jacobson January 12, 2022

Signing of bipartisan infrastructure bill is major step forward for broadband promise

President Joe Biden's promise to expand broadband internet to every American took a major step forward with his signing of the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act on Nov. 15, 2021.

The law included many items from Biden's agenda. It was negotiated by a bipartisan group of senators, then passed with bipartisan support in both the Senate and the House.

The roughly $1 trillion measuer includes sections on roads, bridges, waterways, railways, and the electric grid. But it also includes about $65 billion for improving broadband internet access, particularly in rural areas and for lower-income Americans.

It will send more than $42 billion in grant money to states to improve internet access.

"This bill will help address several issues as it relates to access, affordability, and transparency," Jonathan Schwantes, senior policy counsel at Consumer Reports, wrote shortly after the bill's enactment. "This bipartisan effort is critical for ensuring that more Americans, especially the most vulnerable, have a connection to high-speed internet." 

The investments in the bipartisan infrastructure law come on top of funding included in the American Rescue Plan, the coronavirus and economic relief law signed by Biden just weeks into his presidency. The legislation included $350 billion for states to improve their infrastructure, some of which could be spent on broadband, as well as a separate provision called the Capital Projects Fund that could also be used for broadband projects.

The bill's signing is a major step forward, but we'll hold off on crediting Biden with keeping this promise until we see how smoothly the provisions in the laws are implemented on the ground. This remains In the Works.

Our Sources

Louis Jacobson
By Louis Jacobson June 10, 2021

Biden’s infrastructure plan proposes $100 billion for broadband expansion

Joe Biden made a bold promise as a candidate in 2020 — that he'd expand broadband to every American. It's still early, but he made the pledge concrete by including it in his American Jobs Plan, which was his opening proposal in the quest for an infrastructure bill.

In his proposal, Biden compared the need for broadband Internet to the need to electrify the country generations earlier. He said he would "bring affordable, reliable, high-speed broadband to every American, including the more than 35% of rural Americans who lack access to broadband at minimally acceptable speeds."

Specifically, Biden would spend $100 billion to extend broadband infrastructure in underserved areas, prioritizing support for networks affiliated with local governments, nonprofit groups, and cooperatives.

He also proposed increased transparency and competition among internet providers and opened the door to subsidizing individual users who could not otherwise afford access, but the proposal did not include details.

So far, Biden has introduced only a broad outline of legislation he'd like to see; there is no formal bill yet. And passing legislation — which may or may not ultimately include money for broadband  expansion — promises to be a heavy lift.

In fact, bipartisan negotiations over the American Jobs Plan have so far struggled to produce a workable agreement, amid concerns expressed by Republicans that the program costs too much. And in the Senate, support from 60 senators would be required to advance to a final vote, unless Democrats can find a way to pass a measure using the reconciliation process, which requires only a simple majority.

Still, the inclusion of this promise in a high-profile presidential initiative is enough to move it to In the Works.

Our Sources

Latest Fact-checks