Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
No, this Obama-era law didn’t legalize propaganda and lead to Walz ‘happy warrior’ moniker
If Your Time is short
-
Vice President Kamala Harris and her presidential running mate, Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, have sought to portray themselves as "joyful warriors."
-
News reports and cable news pundits have reported on this approach, and many referred to Walz as a "happy warrior," a common political nickname that dates back at least 100 years. Franklin Delano Roosevelt, who was first elected president in 1932, used it in a speech about New York Gov. Al Smith at the 1924 Democratic National Convention.
-
The Smith-Mundt Modernization Act of 2012, signed into law by President Barack Obama, did not legalize propaganda in the U.S. The law, which has no effect on privately owned news outlets, eased U.S. broadcast restrictions on government-funded media, such as Voice of America.
On the presidential campaign trail, Vice President Kamala Harris and her running mate, Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, have sought to cultivate an image of a positive, joyful message to contrast what they say is Republican nominee Donald Trump’s negative campaign.
Walz says, "We are joyful warriors," Harris recounted Aug. 7 at an Eau Claire, Wisconsin rally, their second joint appearance. It’s been a common theme in their subsequent appearances together.
Many news outlets and opinion pieces have reported on the Harris-Walz strategy, with some referring to Walz as a "happy warrior," chosen by Harris because of his upbeat personality.
An Aug. 13 Instagram post saw a more sinister motive in the media reporting, and blamed a former Democratic president.
The Instagram post shared a video that showed multiple cable news clips with journalists or pundits referring to Walz as a "happy warrior."
The Instagram video’s caption called it "extreme propaganda," and said it was rooted in a Barack Obama-era law.
"It used to be illegal to use media outlets to push propaganda on the American people, it was still covertly done but not as bad as this," the caption said. "Obama legalized government propaganda during his time as president. … Obama’s change to the law is why we are seeing so many news clips all repeating the same Democrat talking points."
But the statement mischaracterizes a law passed during Obama's administration that was related to government-produced media content, not privately owned media such as the cable news outlets seen in the Instagram video.
The term can be traced to "The Character of the Happy Warrior," a 1807 William Wordsworth poem that described someone being brave, generous, having strong morals and other positive traits that "every man in arms should wish to be."
The term emerged in politics by Franklin Delano Roosevelt in 1924, when Roosevelt used it in a speech to describe New York Gov. Alfred Smith while unsuccessfully nominating Smith to be the Democrats’ presidential nominee at the party’s national convention in New York. One Roosevelt scholar said a Smith adviser had added the term to Roosevelt’s speech, The Federalist wrote.
The nickname has been applied to multiple politicians since, including former Republican President Ronald Reagan and former Democratic Vice President and Minnesota Sen. Hubert Humphrey.
Harris and Walz have embraced this image.
"Thank you for bringing back the joy," Walz told Harris after she introduced him as her running mate Aug. 6 in Philadelphia.
Featured Fact-check
The next day at a campaign stop in Eau Claire, Wisconsin, Harris said, "And understand, in this fight, as Tim Walz likes to point out, we are joyful warriors."
She again used the term "joyful warriors" the same day at a Detroit rally. Walz accused Trump and his running mate, Ohio Sen. JD Vance, of trying to "steal the joy" from the country. "Our next president brings the joy. She emanates the joy," Walz said.
Both Harris and Walz referred to campaigning with "joy" at an Aug. 9 Glendale, Arizona, rally. At an Aug. 10 Las Vegas rally, Walz again said Harris "brought out the joy in our politics" and said their work is tough, "but we can be happy doing it."
Despite the Instagram video’s attempt to link the network reporting on this to Obama, it has no connection to the former president. (Although Obama did use the term "happy warrior" to describe then-Vice President Joe Biden in 2012.)
The Instagram post’s narrator referred to a law change during Obama’s administration that she said "legalized government propaganda" and led to the news outlets "repeating the same Democratic talking points."
The post didn’t specify the law but it’s likely referring to Obama’s signing in 2012 of the Smith-Mundt Modernization Act of 2012, which PolitiFact found was the subject of misinformation in 2019.
False social media posts in recent years have said the law legalized government propaganda in the U.S.
The law has no effect on independent, privately owned media outlets, such as CNN, NBC and MSNBC, which were shown in the Instagram video.
The bill Obama signed removed some restrictions on U.S.-funded and generated news produced for overseas audiences from being broadcast to U.S. audiences, such as programming produced by the U.S. Agency for Global Media, which "broadcasts news and information about the United States and the world to audiences abroad."
Among those programs run by the agency are Voice of America, an international broadcaster that reaches an audience of more than 350 million people worldwide. Other agency programs include Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, Radio Free Asia and Middle East Broadcasting Networks.
Before the law was passed, those outlets’ programming could be viewed or listened to in broadcast quality only in foreign countries. Much of that programming was already available in the U.S. online. The change in the law allows content produced by the government to be made available in broadcast quality in the U.S. upon request.
An Instagram post said videos of media talking about Walz as a "happy warrior" are proof of government propaganda legalized by Barack Obama.
The Harris-Walz ticket has sought to portray itself as "joyful warriors." Many news outlets reported on this strategy and used the term "happy warrior" to describe Walz. It’s a common political nickname that has been given to U.S. politicians since at least 1924.
An Obama-era law eased U.S. broadcast restrictions for government-funded news, such as what’s produced by the U.S. Agency for Global Media. The law does not apply to privately owned media companies such as those featured in the Instagram video.
We rate the claim False.
Our Sources
Instagram post, Aug. 13, 2024 (archived)
The Washington Post, Harris and Walz seize on joyful message in contrast to darker Trump themes, Aug. 8, 2024
Arizona Republic, How Fox News, CNN reacted to Kamala Harris' 'fascinating' VP pick Tim Walz, Aug. 6, 2024
Politico, Young voters are looking for ‘fun.’ Democrats hope Walz can bring it., Aug. 6, 2024
USA Today, Walzing on sunshine: How Tim Walz's upbeat demeanor got him on the Kamala Harris ticket, Aug. 10, 2024
CNN, Happy warriors Harris and Walz propose an antidote to Trump’s American carnage, Aug. 7, 2024
William Wordsworth, Poetry Foundation, 'Character of the Happy Warrior', accessed Aug. 14, 2024
George Washington University, Eleanor Roosevelt Papers Project, Alfred Emanuel "Al" Smith (1873-1944), accessed Aug. 14, 2024
Time, National Affairs: THE DEFEAT OF THE HAPPY WARRIOR, April 18, 1960
Eliot Wilson, The Ideas Lab on Substack, The power of the happy warrior, May 5, 2023
Political Dictionary, Happy Warrior, accessed Aug. 14, 2024
United States Senate, Hubert Humphrey: A Featured Biography, accessed Aug. 14, 2024
The Atlantic, Joe Biden Joins a Long Line of 'Happy Warriors', Nov. 7, 2012
The Federalist, Harris Repackages False ‘Happy Warrior’ Claims As Old As FDR, Aug. 14, 2024
The White House, Remarks by Vice President Harris and Governor Tim Walz at a Campaign Event in Philadelphia, PA, Aug. 6, 2024
The White House, Remarks by Vice President Harris and Governor Tim Walz at a Campaign Event | Eau Clarie, WI, Aug. 7, 2024
The White House, Remarks by Vice President Harris and Governor Walz at a Campaign Event in Detroit, MI, Aug. 7, 2024
The White House, Remarks by Vice President Harris and Governor Tim Walz at a Campaign Event in Las Vegas, NV, Aug. 10, 2024
Voice of America, VOA mission, accessed Aug. 14, 2024
Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, About RFE/RL, accessed Aug. 14, 2024
Radio Free Asia, About RFA, accessed Aug. 14, 2024
U.S. Agency for Global Media, Mission, accessed Aug. 14, 2024
U.S. Agency for Global Media, Middle East Broadcasting Networks, accessed Aug. 14, 2024
U.S. Agency for Global Media, Facts About Smith-Mundt Modernization, accessed Aug.14, 2024
Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute, First Amendment, accessed Aug. 14, 2024
PolitiFact,No, Obama didn’t make it legal for media outlets to ‘purposely lie’ to the American public, Aug. 23, 2019
Congress.gov, H.R.4310 - National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2013, accessed Aug. 14, 2024
Congress.gov, H.R.5736 - Smith-Mundt Modernization Act of 2012, accessed Aug. 14, 2024
Browse the Truth-O-Meter
More by Jeff Cercone
No, this Obama-era law didn’t legalize propaganda and lead to Walz ‘happy warrior’ moniker
Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.