No, Bergen County didn’t find more votes for Phil Murphy after all the ballots were counted

New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy beat his Republican challenger Jack Ciattarelli in a tight race that was punctuated with unfounded accusations of voter fraud. 

One image being shared on Facebook shows screenshots of election results posted on the New York Times website. 

"At midnight Bergen County (the biggest county) was 100% reported... and red.." the post said. "By 7:30 AM they ‘found’ 40,000 more votes and flipped to blue?!?!"

The screenshot shows Ciattarelli with 52% of the vote at 12:23 a.m. with 100% of votes reported. The total number of votes shown is 219,984. 

Another screenshot shows Murphy with 52% of the vote at 7:32 a.m., and 100% of votes reported. The total number of votes shown is 261,528.

A similar set of screenshots from election results posted on NPR’s website that are being shared online highlight the same thing. It looks like the vote is "100% in" in Bergen County, but the candidate with the edge shifts from the Republican to the Democrat. 

These posts were flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.)

Featured Fact-check

X posts

stated on October 22, 2024 in posts on X

A photo shows The Atlantic published a story headlined “Trump is Literally Hitler.”

We reached out to the Bergen County clerk’s office about the posts. 

Sabrina Taranto, the elections division supervisor in the Bergen County clerk’s office, told PolitiFact that because of the way the county tallies its votes, 100% means that "70 of the 70 towns in Bergen County’s election day machines were received and counted." 

In this case, 100% does not include other types of votes, such as mail-in ballots, provisional ballots, and early voting ballots.

"This is the standard method followed by our office for every election," Taranto said.

Most of the early voting results were tabulated on election night and then integrated with the election day results on the clerk’s website, she said. After early voting results were finalized on Nov. 3, the results on the website were updated again. 

The Associated Press has called the race for Murphy, but the county’s election results are still unofficial until the election is certified. 

Clearly, some people have been confused by the county’s method for presenting its election results. But it’s not evidence of fraud, and 40,000 weren’t "found" — they were counted. 

We rate claims that Bergen County fraudulently gave more votes to Murphy than Ciattarelli after all ballots were counted False.